$B#1(B $B$O$8$a$K(B



1997$BG/(B7$B7n(B2$BF|$K%?%$@/I\$,0YBX%l!<%H0];}@/:v$rJ|4~$9$k$H!"?t%v7n$NFb$KDL2_Gd$j(B $B05NO$O(BASEAN$B=t9qA40h$KGH5Z$7!"3F9q$G0YBX%l!<%H$NBgI}$J8:2A$H3t<0;X?t$N5^Mn$,(B $B@8$8$?(B($B%"%8%"=t9q$NL>L\0YBX%l!<%H$N?d0\$rI=$7$??^I=(B1$B$*$h$S?^I=(B2$B$r;2(B $B>H!#(B)$B!#$3$l$O0lHLE*(B $B$K!V%"%8%"DL2_4m5!!W$H8F$P$l$k!#:#2s$NDL2_4m5!$NFCD'$O!"DL2_2ACM$N5^Mn$HF1;~(B $B$K!"6d9TItLg$NN.F0@-4m5!$H!":DL3ITMz9T$K$h$k6bM;5!4X$NBgNLGKC>$NH/@8$H$$$&(B $B$$$o$f$k!V6bM;4m5!!W$,H/@8$7$F$$$k$3$H$G$"$k!#=>$C$F!"%"%8%"$N4m5!H/@8%a%+%K(B $B%:%`$rM}2r$9$k>e$G$ODL2_4m5!$H$H$b$K$3$N6bM;4m5!$NB&LL$HDL2_4m5!$H$N4X78$r9M(B $BN8$9$k$3$H$,IT2D7g$G$"$k(B{$B0J8e!"K\%Z!<%Q!<$G$O%"%8%"$GH/@8$7$?0lO"$N(B $B4m5!$r!V%"%8%"DL2_4m5!!W$H8F$V!#0lJ}!"Ej5!967b$K$h$kDL2_2ACM5^Mn$H8GDj0YBX@/(B $B:v$NJx2u$r!VDL2_4m5!!W!"$^$?6d9TIt(B $BLg$NN.F0@-4m5!$"$k$$$O:DL3ITMz9T$K$h$k6bM;5!4X$NBgNLGKC>$r!V6bM;4m5!!W$H8F$S(B $B6hJL$9$k!#(B}$B!#$^$?$=$N6bM;4m5!H/@8$N860x!&9=B$$d?<9o$5$NEY9g$$$O9q$K$h$C$FBg(B $B$-$J:9$,$"$k$N$,8=>u$G$"$j!"%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$N860x$rM}2r!&GD0.$9$k$?$a$K$O3F9q(B $B$N7P:QE*;v>p$rJ,$1$F9M$($k$Y$-$G$"$k!#(B $BK\9F$NZE*(B $B>Z5r$,I,MW$G$"$k!#$=$&$7$?0UL#$GK\9F$K$*$1$k7kO@It$O!V7kO@!W$G$J$/!V6571$H2](B $BBj!W$H$7$FK\9F$,;nO@E*$J$b$N$K$H$I$^$k$3$H<($7$F$$$k!#%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$NH/@8$K(B $B4X$9$k6qBNE*$JZE*8&5f$K$O!"(BAlba, et al.(1998), Corsetti, Pesenti, and Roubini(1998), Dornbusch(1998), Feldstein(1998b), Goldstein(1998), Sachs and Radelet(1998), IMF(1998)$B$J$I$,$"$k!#(B}$B!#$b$A$m$sDL2_4m5!$K$O$=$N=i4|>r7o$d(B $BH/@82aDx$K$=$l$>$l$N8D@-$,$"$k$?$a!"A4$F$N2a5n$K$*$-$?A4$F$N4m5!$K6&DL$9$k5f(B $B6K$NM}O@$dM=KI%^%K%e%"%k$r:n@.$9$k$3$H$OIT2DG=$G$"$k$7!"$b$A$m$s$=$l$OK\9F$N(B $BL\E*$G$b$J$$!#$7$+$7%"%8%"7?4m5!$K4X$7$F%"%8%"DL2_4m5!7?$NDL2_4m5!$r:F$S7+$j(B $BJV$5$J$$$h$&!"$=$N6571$r0z=P$9$3$H$O2DG=$G$"$m$&!#:#$^$G%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$rH/@8(B $B$5$;$?860x$K$D$$$FMM!9$JMW0x$,;XE&$5$l$F$-$?(B{$B%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$K4X$9$k(B $B$C$FMM!9$JJ88%$r9-$/%5!<%Y%$$7!"2DG=$J8B$jFC(B $BDj$N%b%G%k$K0M5r$9$k$3$H$J$/!"%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$NH/@89=B$$rM}2r$7$=$N6571$r0z=P(B $B$7$?$$!#(B $BK\>O$N9=@.$O0J2<$NDL$j$G$"$k!#$^$:Bh(B2$B>O$GDL2_4m5!$r@bL@$9$k:G$b%9%?%s%@!<%I(B $B$JM}O@$G$"$k%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/4m5!H/@8%b%G%k$*$h$S<+8JMh$NDL2_4m5!%b%G%k$G@bL@(B $B$G$-$k$N$+!"$^$?$I$3$,@bL@$G$-$J$$$N$+$r8!F$$9$k(B{$BN>%b%G%k$N@bL@$K$D(B $B$$$F!"$$$:$l$b$=$NL\E*$O%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$r$I$NDxEY@bL@$G$-$F$$$k$N$+$rD>46E*$K(B $BL@Gr$K$9$k$b$N$G$"$j!"M}O@E*87L)@-$rDI5a$9$k$b$N$G$O$J$$!#$J$*K\9F$G$NN>%b%G(B $B%k$N@bL@$O!".@n(B(1998a,1998b)$B$K0M5r$7$F$$$k!#(B}$B!#B3$$$FBh(B3$B>O$G!"%P%V%k$N(B $BH/@8$H6b(B $BM;4m5!$NLr3d$r=E;k$7$?!VAP;R$N4m5!!W$r@bL@$9$kDL2_4m5!H/@8%b%G%k$r@bL@$7!"$=(B $B$l$i$r$U$^$($FBh(B4$B>O$G!"0l9q$GH/@8$7$?DL2_4m5!$,$J$9q$XEA@w$9$k$N$+$r@bL@(B $B$9$k!#Bh(B5$B>O$G!"Bh0l@$Be%b%G%k$K$h$k4m5!H/@8>r7o$rK~$?$7$F$$$?$K$b4X$o$i$:$J(B $B$O$G$O!"ElFn%"%8%"=t9q$X$N;qK\(B $BN.F~$N860x$r3NG'$7!"Bh(B7$B>O$G%?%$$N6bM;%7%9%F%`$N9=B$E*$JLdBjE@$rGD0.$7!"%"%8(B $B%"4m5!$K4X$7$F8@$($PDL2_E*B&LL$HF1;~$K9qFb6bM;%7%9%F%`$N@HO$G!"5^7c$J;qK\N.F~$,$"$C$?$H$-$I$N$h$&$K@/:vBP1~(B $B$9$Y$-$+$r9M$($k!#Bh(B9$B>O$G8GDjAj>l@)$O4|4V8BDjE*AO$G!"0J>e$NN.$l$rF'$^$($F:#2s$N4m5!$+$i6571$r0z$-=P$7!":#8e$N2]Bj(B $B$rDs<($7$?$$!#(B

$B#2(B $B4pK\E*$J#2$D$NDL2_4m5!H/@8%b%G%k(B



$B$3$N>O$G$O!"DL2_4m5!$rM}2r$9$k$?$a$NM-1W$J%U%l!<%`%o!<%/$G$"$kFs$D$N:G$b4p(B $BK\E*$JDL2_4m5!H/@8%b%G%k$r@0M}$7$F$*$-$?$$!#0l$D$O
$B!!(BKrugman(1979)$B$O@/I\$N302_=`Hw9b$K>GE@$rEv$F$F8GDj0YBX%l!<%H$H6bM;@/:v$H$N(B $B%.%c%C%W$,DL2_4m5!$r0z$-5/$3$9$H$$$&$$$o$f$k%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/DL2_4m(B $B5!%b%G%k$r@bL@$7$?(B{Krugman(1979)$B$N4m5!%b%G%k$O!"6b;T>l$K$*$1$k@/I\(B $B$N8GDj6b2A3J$KBP$9$kEj5!967b$rJ,@O$r9T$C$?(BSalant and Henderson(1978)$B$N%b%G%k(B $B$r!"309q0YBX;T>l$K$*$1$k8GDj0YBX%l!<%H$X$NEj5!967b$NJ,@O$K1~MQ$7$?$b$N$G$"(B $B$k!#(B}$B!#$=$N8e!"(BKrugman$B$N%b%G%k$r4pAC$K$7$F!"(BFlood and Garber(1984)$B$O!V%7%c(B $B%I!.@n(B (1998a,1998b)$B$J$I!#0J2<$N@bL@$O.@n(B(1998a, 1998b)$B$K=`5r$7$F$$$k!#(B}$B!#(B

$B!c>u67$N@_Dj!d(B

$B$^$:>.9q3+J|7P:Q$rA[Dj$7!"DL2_Ev6I$O:G=i!"8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$7$F$$$k$H$9$k!#(B $B@/I\$ONc$($P:b@/@V;z$rOE$&$?$a$KDL2_Ev6I$KDL2_$rH/9T$5$;BP@/I\?.MQ$r3HBg$9(B $B$k!#$"$k$$$O!"DL2_Ev6I$,B>$NM}M3$K$h$C$FBPL14V?.MQ$r3HBg$9$k!#DL2_H/9T$K$h$k(B $B:b@/@V;z$ND4C#$OH/E8ES>e9q$GE57?E*$K8+$i$l$k@/:v%Q%?!<%s$G$"$k!#$3$l$i$NBP(B $B@/I\?.MQ$dBPL14V?.MQ$O9qFb?.MQ;D9b$H$7$F$"$k0lDj$N@.D9N($G@.D9$9$k$3$H$K$J(B $B$k!#?^I=(B3$B$K$F9qFb?.MQ$,3HD%$7$D$D$"$k>u67$rI=$7$F$$$k!#8GDj0YBXAj>l@)$r0];}(B $B$9$k$?$a$K$O!"9qFb30$NJ*2A>e>:N($N:9$,9-$,$C$F$O$J$i$J$$$N$G!"L>L\2_J>6!5k;D(B $B9b$N@.D9N($O%<%m$G$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#=>$C$F!"302_=`Hw9b$O9qFb?.MQ$N@.D9N($HF1(B $BN($N@.D9N($G8:>/$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#$J$<$J$i!"$b$79qFb?.MQ$,@.D9$9$k0lJ}$G30(B $B2_=`Hw$,JQ2=$7$J(B $B$1$l$P%^%M!<%5%W%i%$$,A}Bg2=$7!"$=$l$OJ*2A$N>e>:$rDL$8$F<+9qDL2_$N8:2A05NO$H(B $B$J$k$+$i$G$"$k!#$=$N$?$a8GDjAj>l@)$r0];}$9$k$?$a$K$ODL2_Ev6I$,302_$rGd$C$F<+(B $B9qDL2_$rGc(B $B$$;Y$($kI,MW$,$"$j!"302_=`Hw$,8:>/$9$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$"$kEj5!2H$O302_=`Hw$,?T$-$k(B $B$^$GEj5!967b$rBT$H$&$H$9$k$+$b$7$l$J$$!#302_=`Hw$,?T$-$l$P@/I\$O8GDjAj>l@)$N(B $BJ|4~$rM>57$J$/$5$l!"JQF0Aj>l@)$K3N$C$F!"Ej5!2H$,302_$K8r49$7(B $B$h$&$H$9$k<+9qDL2_$N=jM-3[!JFC$KC;4|BP30r7o$rK~$?$9$H8@$($k!#$D$^$jCf1{6d9T$N30(B $B2_=`Hw9b$HC;4|BP30r7o$rK~$?$9;~E@$G$"(B $B$k!#$7$+$7!"Ej5!2H$O$3$N;~E@0JA0$K$bEj5!967b$r5/$3$9%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r;}$D!#$J(B $B$<$J$i!"$b$7B>$NEj(B $B5!2H$,@h$KEj5!$r$7$+$1$FJQF0Aj>l@)$K0\9T$7$F$7$^$&$HEj5!$K$h$kMx1W$,$b$O$dF@(B $B$i$l$J$$$+$i$G$"$k!#Ej5!2H$,$$$D8GDjAj>l@)$KEj5!$r$7$+$1$k$+$H$$$&!VEj5!$N%?(B $B%$%_%s%0!W$r%7%c%I!l$H$$$&35G0$rMQ$$$F@bL@$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B

$B!cEj5!967b$N%?%$%_%s%0!d(B

$B%7%c%I!l$H$O!"!V8=l@)$,:NMQ$5$l$F$$$k$"$k9q$G!"$b$7JQF0(B $BAj>l@)$,:NMQ$5$l$F$$$l$Pl$r8:2A$5$;$k!#?^I=(B3$B$N2<(B $BH>J,$O$3(B $B$N>u67$r<($7$F$$$k!#$3$3$G!"$"$kEj5!2H$,%7%c%I!l$,8=9T$N8GDj0YBXAj>l(B $B$KC#$7$?;~E@$rI=$9;~E@(BT$B$h$j$bAa$$;~E@$GEj5!967b$r$7$+(B $B$1$FJQF0Aj>l@)$X0\9T$5$;$k$H!"H`$NMx1W$O%^%$%J%9$K$J$k!#$J$<$J$iH`$O8=9T$N8G(B $BDjAj>l@)$G$N0YBX%l!<%H$G<+9qDL2_$rGc$C$F!"%7%c%I!l$N?e=`$G<+9qDL2_$r(B $BGd$k$3$H$K$J$k$+$i$G$"$k!#0lJ}!";~E@(BT$B0J9_$GEj5!967b$r$+$1$FJQF0Aj>l@)$X0\9T(B $B$5$;$k$H!"Ej5!2H$OEj5!$K$h$k%W%i%9$NMx1W$rF@$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#=>$C$FEj5!$,5/$3(B $B$j$&$k$N(B $B$O!"%7%c%I!l$,8=9T$N8GDjAj>l$KC#$7$?;~4|$rI=$9;~E@(BT$B0J9_$G$"$k$3$H$,(B $B$o$+$k!#(B

$B$3$3$G!"%7%c%I!l$,8=9T8GDjAj>l$rD6$($F8:2A$7B3$1(B $B$F$$$k>uBV$G$b!"Ej5!2H$OEj5!$K$h$kMx1W$r:GBg2=$7$h$&$H$7$F0lDj4|4VBT5!$7$h$&(B $B$H$$$&%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r;}$D!#%7%c%I!l$H8GDjAj>l$N:9$,9-$,$l$P9-$,$k$[(B $B$IEj5!$K$h$kMx1W$OBg$-$/$J$k$+$i$G$"$k!#0lJ}$GEj5!2H$O!"$b$7B>$NEj5!2H$,@h$K(B $BEj5!967b$r$7(B $B$+$1$FJQF0Aj>l@)$K0\9T$7$F$7$^$&$H$b$O$dEj5!$K$h$kMx1W$,K>$a$J$$$H$$$&%8%l%s(B $B%^$K$b$"$k!#7kO@E*$K$O!"Ej5!967b$O%7%c%I!l$,8GDjAj>l$KC#$9$k$HF1;~$K(B $B!J$D$^$j;~E@(BT$B$K$*$$$F!KH/@8$9$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B!c$3$N%b%G%k$N4^0U!d(B

$B!!$3$N%b%G%k$O$^$:!"<+9qDL2_$K8:2A05NO$,$+$+$j%7%c%I!<0YBXAj>l$,8:2A$7B3$1$k(B $B>uBV$K$*$$$F$O!"8GDjAj>l@)$,Aa$+$lCY$+$l$$$:$l$OJx2u$7$F$7$^$&$3$H$r4^0U$9(B $B$k!#$D$^$j!"8GDjAj>l@)$N2<$G9qFb?.MQ$,3HBg$7B3$1$k$H$$$&>r7o$N$b$H$GI,A3E*$K(B $BH/@8$9$k!#$=$7$F$=$NDL2_4m5!H/@8$N%?%$%_%s%0$K$D$$$F!"0J2<$N(B3$BE@$,=EMW$J;XI8(B $B$G$"$k$3$H$r<($7$F$$$k!#(B

(1)$B!V302_=`Hw3[!W!'302_=`Hw3[$,C;4|BP30:DL3;D9b$r2<2s$C$?;~!"Ej5!967b$NH/@8(B $B>r7o$rK~$?$9!#(B
(2)$B!V9qFb?.MQ@.D9N(!W!'9qFb?.MQ@.D9N($,$,9b$1$l$P9b$$$[$I!"DL2_4m5!$N%?%$%_(B $B%s%0$,Aa$^$k!#(B
(3)$B!V:b@/@V;z!W!':b@/@V;z$,Bg$-$1$l$PBg$-$$$[$I!"9qFb?.MQ@.D9N($r9b$a!"DL2_(B $B4m5!$N%?%$%_%s%0$,Aa$^$k!#(B
$B%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/4m5!H/@8%b%G%k$K=>$($P!"$3$l$i$N(B3$B$D$,DL2_4m5!H/@8(B $B$N=EMW$J@h9T;XI8$K@.$jF@$k$G$"$m$&!#(B

$B$3$3$GCmL\$9$Y$-$3$H$O!"%$%s%I%M%7%"!"4Z9q!"%?%$$N(B3$B9q$G$O302_=`Hw3[$,C;4|BP(B $B30:DL3;D9b$r2<2s$C$?>uBV$,B3$$$F$$$?$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k(B{$B?^I=(B4$B$r;2(B $B>H!#(B}$B!#%/%k!<%0%^%s$O@/I\$,:b@/3HBg@/:v$r9T$&$3$H$G302_=`Hw$rAS<:$7B3$1$k$H(B $B$$$&>u67$rA[Dj$7$F$$$k!#0lJ}$GEl%"%8%"=t9q$G$OCf1{6d9T$r4^$`302_=`Hw3[$OA}2C(B $B798~$K$"$j!"%/%k!<%0%^%s$NA[Dj$9$k4m5!%b%G%k$H$OI,$:$7$b$=$N2aDx$G$O0lCW$7$J(B $B$$!#$7$+$7C;4|BP30:DL3$,5^7c$KA}Bg$7$?$?$a$KH`$N%b%G%k$K$h$k>e$N(B(1)$B$NDL2_4m(B $B5!H/@8$N>r7o$rK~$?$7$F$$$?$H8@$&$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$J$<%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/(B $BDL2_4m5!$NH/@8>r7o$rK~$?$7$F$$$?$K$b4X$o$i$:DL2_4m5!H/@8$OM=B,$5$l$J$+$C$?$N(B $B$+!"$^$?!"$J$r7o$rK~$?$7$?;~E@$G4m5!$,H/@8$7$J$+$C$?$N$+$r8!F$$9$kI,MW(B $B$,$"$k!#$3$NE@$OBh(B5$B>O$G8!F$$9$k$3$H$K$9$k!#(B

2.2 $B<+8J
$BA0@a$G@bL@$7$?Bh0l@$Be%b%G%k$O%^%/%m7P:Q$N%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:0-2=$,8GDj0YBX(B $B%l!<%H$H$N%.%c%C%W$rH/@8$5$;!"Ej5!967b$r0z$-5/$3$9$H$$$&$b$N$G$"$C$?!#$3$l$K(B $BBP$7$F0lO"$NZJ,@O(B{Rose and Svensson(1994)$B$*$h$S(BEichengreen, Rose, and Wyplosz(1994,1995)$B!#(B}$B$O!"2$=#DL2_4m5!$K4X$7$F$O%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:(B $B$,0-2=$7$F$$$J$$$K$b4X$o$i$:Ej5!967b$,H/@8$7$F$$$k$3$H$r;XE&$7$F$$$k!#$3$l$r(B $B
$B!c>u67$N@_Dj!d(B

$BFs$D$N%b%G%k$O$$$:$l$b-Mh$NM=;;@)Ls$NCf$G302_=`Hw$r<+M3$K9q:];T>l$GDj$7$F$$$J$$$?$a!"Bh0l@$Be4m5!%b%G(B $B%k$H0[$J$j!"30(B $B2_=`Hw9b$=$l<+BN$ODL2_4m5!H/@8$d$=$N%?%$%_%s%0$r7hDj$7$J$$!#Bh(B2$B$K!"%$%s%U%l(B $BN($H(B $B<:6HN($,C;4|E*$K%U%#%j%C%W6J@~$N7A>u$r$7$F$*$j!"@/I\$O8=e$G%$%s%U%lN($H<:6HN($N4V$N%H%l!<%I%*%U$NCf$+$iK>$^$7$$E@$rA*Br$9$k(B $B$3$H$,$G$-$k!#Bh(B3$B$K!"@/I\$ODL2_@Z$j2<$2$r9T$&$H8GDjAj>l@)$KBP$9$k?.Mj$,Dc2<(B $B$9$k;v$rCN$C$F(B $B$*$j!"$=$N$h$&$J8GDjE*$JHs6bA,E*%3%9%H$r$b9MN8$7$F%$%s%U%lM^@)$d<:6HBP:v$J$I(B $B$N%^%/%m7P:Q@/:v$r9T$C$F$$$k!#DL2_@Z2<$2$r8GDjE*HqMQ$H$_$J$9;~!"@/I\$O$=$N8G(B $BDjHqMQ$rD6$($J$$HO0O$N>.$5$J6!5k%7%g%C%/$KBP$7$F$O8GDj0YBX@)$r0];}$9$k$[$&$,(B $BK>$^$7$$!#$7$+$78GDjHqMQ$r>e2s$k$H;W$o$l$kBg$-$J6!5k%7%g%C%/$,5/$3$C$?;~!"@/(B $BI\$O8GDjAj>l@)$rJ|4~$7$FDL2_$r@Z$j2<$2$k$[$&$,K>$^$7$$!#2?8N$J$i!"DL2_$r@Z$j(B $B2<$2$k$3$H$K$h$C$F8GDjAj>l@)$KBP$9$k?.Mj$,Dc2<$9$k$H$$$&%3%9%H$h$j$b!"$=$N6!(B $B5k%7%g%C%/$N1F6A$rl$r0];}$9$k$H$$$&4pK\E*$J@/:vJ}?K$r:N$j$J$,$i$b!"Bg$-$J%7%g%C%/$KBP$7(B $B$F$ODL2_@Z2<$2$r9T$&$H$$$&!VLH@U>r9`(B(escape clause)$B!W$N$D$$$?0YBXAj>l@/:v$r(B $B:N$k$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!#(B

$B!c;:=PNL%7%g%C%/!d(B

$B$^$:;:=PNL%7%g%C%/$K>GE@$rEv$F$k%b%G%k$r@bL@$9$k(B {Obstfeld(1994,1996)$B$r;2>H!#$J$*!"$3$3$G@bL@$9$k%b%G%k$O!"(BBarro and Gordon(1983)$B!"$*$h$S!"(BKydland and Prescott(1977)$B$N%b%G%k$r3+J|7P:Q%b%G%k$K1~(B $BMQ$5$;$?$b$N$G$"$k!#(B}$B!#>e5-$7$?2>Dj$N$b$H$G!"@/I\$O!"L14V%$%s%U%lN(4|BTCM$r(B $B=jM?$H$7$?$H$-!"L14V7P:Ql@)$N2<$G$O!"%$%s%U%lN($N>e>:$O<+9q$NDL2_2ACM$rDc2<$5$;$k$N$G!"L\0YBX%l!<%H!"(BPw $B$O3$30$NJ*2A?e=`!"(BP$B$O<+9q$NJ*2A?e=`$G$"(B $B$k(B)$B!"8GDjAj>l@)$N2<$G$OL>L\0YBX%l!<%H$OITJQ$G$"$k$N$G!"<+9q$G%$%s%U%l$,H/@8(B $B$7(BP$B$,>e>:$9$k$Hl$r8:2A$5$;$k!#$D$^$jL14V7P:Qe8B$*$h$S2<8B$O!"4|BT0YBX%l!<%H$NJQ2=N($K0M(B $BB8$9$k!#$D$^$j!"4|BT0YBXAj>l$NJQ2=N($,9b$/$J$l$P!J;T>l$N4|BT%$%s%U%lCM$,9b$1(B $B$l$P!K!"@/I\$,DL2_D4@0$r$9$Y$-;:=PNL%7%g%C%/$N>e8B$H2<8B$NI}$O69$/$J$k!#5U(B $B$K!"4|BT0YBXAj>l$NJQ2=N($,Dc$/$J$l$P!J;T>l$N4|BT%$%s%U%lCM$,Dc$1$l$P!K!"$3$l(B $B$i$N>e8B$H2<8B$NI}$O9-$/$J$k!#=>$C$F!"F1$85,LO$N;:=PNL%7%g%C%/$G$b!"L14V7P:Q(B $Bl$NJQ2=N($K0MB8$7$F!"DL2_D4@0$,9T$o$l$k$Y$-$+!"8GDjAj>l@)EY(B $B$r0];}$9$Y$-$+$,7hDj$5$l$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B!!(B $B!!8@$$49$($l$P!"@/I\$,DL2_$r@Z$j2<$2$J$$$@$m$&$HL14V7P:Qr9`$H$7$F(B $BDL2_@Z2<$2$,9T$o$l$kHO0O$O69$^$j!"DL2_$O@Z$j2<$2$i$l$J$$!#5U$K!"@/I\$,DL2_$r(B $B@Z$j2<$2$k$@$m$&$HL14V7P:Qr9`$H$7$FDL2_@Z2<$2(B $B$,9T$o$l$kHO0O$,9-$/$J$j!"DL2_@Z2<$2$,9T$o$l0W$$>uBV$K$J$k!#@/I\$,<+9qDL2_$r(B $B8:2A$5$;$?$$$H$$$&%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r;}$C$F$$$k$HL14V7P:Ql$NJQ2=N($,9b$^$j!"4|BT0YBXAj>l$NJQ2=N($,>.$5$1$l$P8GDj0YBXAj>l$r0](B $B;}$G$-$k>u67$G$"$C$?$K$b4X$o$i$:!"DL2_D4@0$r9T$o$6$k$rF@$J$$>u67$K$J$k!#$3$N(B $B%b%G%k$N7kO@$O!"Ej5!967b$rH/@8$5$;$kMW0x$O!"9qFb7P:Q%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$N0-2=(B $B$G$O$J$/!"DL2_$,@Z$j2<$2$i$l$k$+!"@Z$j2<$2$i$l$J$$$+$H$$$&L14V7P:Q
$B!cC;4|:DL3$N
Obstfeld(1994)$B$O!"<+9q@/I\$N:DL3$,<+9qDL2_7z$F$GI=<($5$l$k0lJ}!":D8"$,309q(B $BDL2_7z$F$GI=<($5$l$k$3$H$rA[Dj$9$k(B{Obstfeld(1994)$B$G$O!"<+9q@/I\$N:D(B $BL3$,<+9qDL2_7z$FI=<($G$"$k0lJ}!":D7t$,309qDL2_7z$FI=<($G$"$k$3$H$rA[Dj$7$F$$(B $B$k!#$7$+$7CfFnJFDL2_4m5!$d%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$K$*$$$F$O!"309qDL2_7z$F$NC;4|:DL3$N(B $B.@n(B(1998)$B$O!"<+9q@/I\$N:DL3$O<+9qDL2_7z$F$H(B $B309qDL2_7z$F$NN>J}$K$h$C$FI=<($5$l$F$$$k$3$H$rA[Dj$7$?%b%G%k$G<+8J\@b$7$F$$$k!#$7$+$7$3$3$G$N@bL@$G$OD>46E*M}2r$rM%@h$5$;$=$N$h$&(B $B$JM}O@E*87L)@-$ODI5a$7$J$$!#(B}$B!#<+9qDL2_7z$F$NC;4|:DL3$K$h$C$Fe>:$O@/I\$N:DL3IiC4$NA}Bg$r0UL#$9$k!#2?8N$J$i!"<+9qDL(B $B2_7z$FMx;RN($,4|BT0YBX8:2AN($rH?1G$9$k$+$i$G$"$k!#@/I\$N:DL3IiC4$,A}Bg$9$k(B $B$H!"@/I\$OL14V7P:Qe>:$r0z(B $B$-5/$3$9$3$H$G:DL3$NIiC4$r7Z8:$5$;$h$&$H$9$k%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r;}$D!#$3$N$3$H$,(B $BL14V7P:Qe>:$K$h$C$F<+9qDL2_7z$F$N(B $BMx;RN($,$5$i$K9b$^$k$@$m$&!#$3$N$?$a$K@/I\$O$5$i$K0YBX@Z2<$2$*$h$S%$%s%U%lN((B $B>e>:$X$N%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r9b$a$k!#$3$N$h$&$K$7$FDL2_4m5!$,<+8J
$B!c$3$N%b%G%k$N4^0U!d(B

$B!!BhFs@$Be4m5!%b%G%k$N7kO@$O!"Ej5!967b$,L5$1$l$P$h$jD94|E*$K;}B3$G$-$?$G$"$m(B $B$&8GDjAj>l@)$,!"$"$k2?$i$+$NITE,Ev$J>pJs$K$h$C$F0YBX%l!<%H$,;}B32DG=(B (sustainable)$B$J(B $B$b$N$G$O$J$$$HH=CG$7$?L14V7P:Q
(1) $B!!$b$7Ej5!967b$,%^%/%m7P:Q$N%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$HL54X78$KL14V7P:Ql@)$rJ|4~$7$?$$$H$$$&%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r9b$a$k$h$&$J;v7o!"8=>]!"%K%e!<%9!"(B $B1=$J$I$"$i$f$k$b$N$K$J$jF@$h$&!#DL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$K$OL14V7P:QH!#(B}$B!#DL2_4m5!$,<+8JO$G9T$&$3$H$K$9$k!#(B

(2) $B!!A0>O$G8+$?$h$&$K!"%?%$$d%$%s%I%M%7%"$J$I$G$OBP30:DL33[$,302_=`(B $BHw$r>e2s$j!"!J$=$l$K;j$k2aDx$O0[$J$k$b$N$N!K%/%k!<%0%^%s$NBh0l@$Be%b%G%k$K$h(B $B$k4m5!$rH/@8$5$;$k>r7o$rK~$?$7$F$$$?$H8@$($k!#$K$b4X$o$i$:!"DL2_4m5!$O$=$N;~(B $BE@$G$OH/@8$7$J$+$C$?!#$G$O%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$O$3$N%b%G%k$N@bL@$9$k$h$&$K<+8J$($P!"DL2_4m5!$r<+8J$C$F!"8=\:Y$K$D$$$F$OBh(B5$B>O$G>\$7$/8!F$$9$k!#(B

$B!!$^$?!"<+8JH!#(B}$B!#Bh0l$K!"(B $BBh0l@$Be%b%G%k$,7P:Q%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$,;}B3E*$K0-2=$7$F$$$k>uBV$rA[Dj$7!"Ej(B $B5!967b$N%?%$%_%s%0$K>GE@$rEv$F$FJ,@O$r9T$C$F$$$k$N$KBP$7!"BhFs@$Be%b%G%k$O!"(B $B$3$&$7$?D94|E*$J%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$N0-2=$rL5;k$7$F$$$k!#BhFs$K!"<+8Jl9g$O@.N)$7F@$J$/(B $B$J$k!#(B

$B$3$N$h$&$K!"BhFs@$Be%b%G%k$O$=$N2>Dj$NCV$-J}$KLdBj$,$"$k$3$H$,;XE&$5$l$F$*(B $B$j!"%b%G%k$=$N$b$N$KBP$9$kHcH=$r9MN8$7$F$*$/I,MW$,$"$k!#FC$K%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$K(B $B$O3N

$B#3(B $BAP;R$N4m5!(B



$BBh0l@$Be%b%G%k!"BhFs@$Be%b%G%k$H$b2a5n$NDL2_4m5!$rM}2r$9$k$KEv$?$C$FM-MQ$J%U(B $B%l!<%`%o!<%/$H$J$C$F$/$l$k$,!"$3$l$i$N%b%G%k$K$h$C$F8=
(1) $BA0=R$7$?$,!"%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/DL2_4m5!%b%G%k$,A[Dj$9$k$h$&$J@/I\(B $B;Y=P$N3HBg$H$=$l$KH<$&302_=`Hw$NAS<:$H$$$&7QB3E*$J>u67$O%"%8%"=t9q$G$OEv$F$O(B $B$^$i$J$$!#$G$O$3$N%b%G%k$OEl%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$r@bL@$9$k$b$N$H$7$FA4$/E*$r30$7$?(B $B$b$N$G$"$m$&$+!#3N$+$K!"%/%k!<%0%^%s$N2>Dj$9$k$h$&$J>u67$O8+$i$l$J$+$C$?$,!"(B $BEl%"%8%"=t9q$G$OBP30:DL3;D9b$,5^7c$KA}Bg$7!"FC$K%?%$!"4Z9q!"%$%s%I%M%7%"$G$O(B $B$=$l$O302_=`Hw3[$r>e2s$C$F$$$?!#$D$^$j302_=`Hw$,!V?T$-$?!W>uBV$G$"$C$?$H8@$&(B $B$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$^$?!">CHqe9q$K$7$F(B $B$O6K$a$FDc$+$C$?$?$a<+9qDL2_$K8:2A05NO$,$+$+$C$F$$$?$H$O8@$$Fq$$$H$9$k@b$b$"(B $B$k$,!">/$J$/$H$b%I%k$K<+9qDL2_2ACM$r$Z%C%0$7$F$$$k9q$K$H$C$F!"%I%k$N%$%s%U%l(B $BN($h$j$b<+9qDL2_$N%$%s%U%lN($,9b$$>uBV$,B3$1$P(B{$BEl%"%8%"=t9q$N%$%s%U(B $B%lN($O?^I=(B5$B$r!"%^%M!<%5%W%i%$A}2CN($O?^I=(B6$B$r;2>H!#(B}$B!"I,A3E*$KBP%I%k0YBX%l!<(B $B%H$N$C$F%"%8%"4m5!$OBh0l@$Be%b%G%k$K$h$k4m5!H/@8(B $B2aDx$H$O0[$J$C$F$$$k$b$N$N!"$=$l$,0UL#$9$k4pK\E*$J4m5!H/@8>r7o$rK~$?$7$F$$$?(B $B$H$$$($k!#(B

(2) $B%"%8%"=t9q$N7P:Q@.D9$K1"$j$,8+$(;O$a$?(B1996$BG/:"!"<:6HN($O9b$/$J$+$C$?!#$D(B $B$^$j8GDjAj>l@)$rJ|4~$7$h$&$H$$$&%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$O@/I\$K$OL5$+$C$?!#$D$^$jBh(B2 $B@$Be%b%G%k$K$h$k4m5!H/@8%a%+%K%:%`$N$_$G@bL@$9$k$3$H$K$O8B3&$,$"$k!#(B

(3) $BDL2_4m5!0JA0$N%"%8%"=t9q$K$O;q;:2A3J$N5^F-$H$$$&=j0b%P%V%k8=>]$,H/@8$7$F(B $B$$$?!#2?8N%P%V%k$,H/@8$7$?$N$+$r8!F$$9$kI,MW$,$"$k!#(B

(4) $BDL2_4m5!$r7P83$7$?%"%8%"=t9q$G$O!"4m5!$NH/@8$K4X$7$F6bM;5!4X$,$=$NCf?4E*(B $BLr3d$N0lC6$rC4$C$F$$$?$H9M$($i$l$k!#El%"%8%"=t9q$N6bM;5!4X$N9TF0$N2?$,LdBj$G(B $B$"$C$?$N$+!"8!F$$9$kI,MW$,$"$k!#(B

$BFC$K>e$N(B(3)$B!"(B(4)$B$O!"(B1994$BG/$NCfFnJFDL2_4m5!$d(B1997$BG/$N%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$KDL2_4m5!(B $B$HF1;~$KH/@8$7$?6bM;4m5!$r@bL@$9$k$?$a$K=EMW$J8!F$%]%$%s%H$G$"$k$H;W$o$l$k!#(B $B$3$NDL2_4m5!$H6bM;4m5!$H$N0x2L4X78$rM}2r$9$k$3$H(B $B$O!"DL2_4m5!$rKI$0$H$$$&E@$K$D$$$F$b!"DL2_4m5!$,5/$3$C$?;~$K$I$NMM$KBP1~$9$Y(B $B$-$+$H$$$&E@$K$*$$$F$b=EMW$J0UL#$r;}$C$F$$$k!#$=$3$G!"DL2_4m5!$H6bM;4m5!$,$*(B $B8_$$$K$I$N$h$&$K4X78$7$"$C$F$$$k$N$+$r@0M}$7$F$*$-$?$$(B{$BDL2_4m5!$H(B $B6bM;4m5!$N0-=[4D$rM}2r$9$k$?$a$K$=$l$>$l$,M?$($k1F6A$rJ,$1$F9M;!$7$h$&$H$7$F(B $B$$$k$N$G$"$C$F!"$I$A$i$N4m5!$,$h$jK\O$NL\E*$G$O$J$$!#(B}

3.1 $B6bM;4m5!$,0z$-5/$3$9DL2_4m5!(B

$B6bM;4m5!$,DL2_4m5!$r0z$-5/$3$9$H$$$&4X78$O!"A0=R$7$?Bh0l@$Be%b%G%k$*$h$SBhFs(B $B@$Be%b%G%k$r1~MQ$9$k$3$H$G@bL@$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B

($BBh0l@$Be%b%G%k$K$h$kEA@w$N@bL@(B)

$B6bM;4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$HCf1{6d9T$,:G8e$NB_$7@\E*$K9qFb?.MQ$rA}Bg$5(B $B$;$k!#$D$^$j%P%V%k$NH/@8!&Jx2u$H$$$&2aDx$r7P$F6bM;5!4X$NITNI:D8"$,A}Bg2=$76b(B $BM;4m5!$,H/@8$7$?:]!"@/I\$,9qFb?.MQ$r3HBg$7$F;vBV$N2r7h$r?^$m$&$H$9$k!#$HF1;~(B $B$K(B $B@/I\$,8GDjAj>l@)$r$b0];}$7$h$&$H$9$k$H!"%7%c%I!l$,8:2A$7B3$1!"$=$l$,8GDj0YBXAj>l$rD6$($k$dH]$dEj5!967b$,H/@8$7!"DL2_4m5!$,(B $B$*$3$k!#$3$l$,(B($BBh0l@$Be%b%G%k(B)$B%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/DL2_4m5!%b%G%k$N7kO@(B $B$G$"$k!#$3$N$h$&$K6bM;4m5!$O9qFb?.MQ$N3HBg$rDL$8$FDL2_4m5!$r0z$-5/$3$9!#(B

($BBhFs@$Be%b%G%k$N1~MQ(B)

$B$7$+$7!"6bM;4m5!$NH/@8$K:]$7$F!"(B(1)$BCf1{6d9T$,:G8e$NB_$7r7o$,K~$?$5$l$J$/$H$b!"DL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k2DG=@-$,(B $B$"$k!#2?8N$J$i!"$=$&$7$?9TF0$K$h$C$FCf1{6d(B $B9T$d@/I\$,6bM;4m5!$KBP1~$9$k$@$m$&$HL14VEj5!2H$K$h$C$FM=A[$5$l$k$@$1$G!"<+8J(B $Bl9g$K$b!"<+8J
3.2 $BDL2_4m5!$,0z$-5/$3$96bM;4m5!(B

$B0lJ}!"DL2_4m5!$,6bM;4m5!$r0z$-5/$3$9%a%+%K%:%`$O0J2<$N$h$&$K@bL@$5$l$k!#(B

($B0YBX8:2A$K$h$kITNI:D8"A}Bg(B)

$B$^$:!"DL2_4m5!$,6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$KM?$($k1F6A(B {IMF(1997)$B$r;2>H!#(B}$B$G$"$k!#DL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$HEvA3$N$3$H$J$,$i<+9q(B $BDL2_$,BgI}$K8:2A$9$k!#$b$79qFb$N6d9T$,309qDL2_7z$F:DL3$K$h$C$F;q6b$rD4C#$9$k(B $B0lJ}$G0YBX%j%9%/$r$X%C%8$7$J$$$^$^$=$N;q6b$r<+9qDL2_7z$F$GM;;q$7$F$$$k$H$7$?(B $B$i!"<+9qDL2_$NBgI}8:2A$OD>@\E*$K9qFb$N6d9T$r:DL3D62a$K$9$k$@$m$&!#El%"%8%"=t(B $B9q$N6bM;5!4X$,309q$+$i;q6b$rD4C#$9$k:]$K!"0YBX%j%9%/$r$X%C%8$9$k$3$H$O6K$a$F(B $B$^$l$G$"$C$?!#$J$<$J$i!"3F9q$H$b;ve$N8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$7$F$$$?0Y!"0YBXAj>l(B $B$O6K$a$F0BDj$7$F$$$?$+$i$G$"$k!#$D$^$j4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$^$G0YBXJQF0%j%9%/$O3'L5(B $B$KEy$7$+$C$?$o$1$G!"$=$&$7$?%j%9%/$KBP$9$k7Y2|46$OEl%"%8%"=t9q$N6bM;5!4X$K$O(B $B$[$H$s$IL5$+$C$?$N$G$"$k!#(B

( $B6bM;%Q%K%C%/$HN.F0@-4m5!(B)

$B!c6bM;%Q%K%C%/!d(B

$B$^$?!"DL2_$,BgI}$K2
$B!cN.F0@-4m5!!d(B

$B$^$?!"9qFb6d9T$,C;4|$G309q$+$il9g!"$3$NC;4|;q6b(B $B$+$iD94|;q6b$X$NK~4|JQ49$H$$$&6d9T$N4pK\E*5!G=$=$N$b$N$,!"6bM;4m5!$HDL2_4m5!(B $B$r0z$-5/$3$93NN)$r9b$a!"$+$D4m5!$rA}I}$5$;$kLr3d$r2L$?$7$F$$$k$H$9$k;XE&$b$G(B $B$-$h$&(B{Goldfajn and Valdes(1997)$B$O!"6d9T
3.3 $B@$3&Mx;RN($NJQF0$K$h$kAP;R$N4m5!H/@8%b%G%k(B

$B$3$l$^$G!"!J(BA)$B6bM;4m5!$,DL2_4m5!$rH/@8$5$;$k%a%+%K%:%`$H!"!J(BB$B!KDL2_4m5!$,6b(B $BM;4m5!$rH/@8$5$;$k%a%+%K%:%`$HJ,$1$F$=$l$>$l@bL@$7$F$-$?!#0lJ}$G!"DL2_4m5!$H(B $B6bM;4m5!$N0x2L4X78$O=EMW$G$O$J$/!"Fs$D$N4m5!$O$`$7$m@$3&6bMx$NJQF0$H$$$C$?30(B $B@8E*MW0x$K$h$C$F!VF1;~H/@8!W$9$k2DG=@-$,$"$k$3$H$,;XE&$5$l$F$$$k(B{$B0J(B $B8e!"!V@$3&Mx;RN($NJQF0$K$h$k4m5!H/@8%b%G%k!W$H8F$V!#$J$*$3$N%b%G%k$O!"%U%!%s(B $B%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/4m5!H/@8%b%G%k$H<+8J
$B@$3&Mx;RN($,Dc2<$9$k$H$$$&30E*$JMW0x$K$h$C(B $B$F!"<+9qFb$KBgNL$N;q6b$,5^7c$KN.F~$9$k2DG=@-$,$"$k!#$=$N$H$-ITB[2=Ey$NE,@Z$J(B $B@/:v$,:N$i$l$J$$!"$"$k$$$O$=$&$7$?@/:v$rl$,B8:_$7$J$$!"(B $B$^$?$OE,@Z$J6bM;Cg2p$,9T$o$l$J$$Ey$NMM!9$JMW0x(B{$B9qFb$K%P%V%k$rH/@8$5(B $B$;$k6bM;%7%9%F%`$NLdBjE@$O2?$+$rBh(B7$B>O$G9M;!$7$?!#$^$?!"5^7c$K;q6b$r9qFbN.F~(B $B$5$;$kMW0x$O2?$+!"$^$?5^7c$J;qK\N.F~05NO$KBP$7$F$I$NMM$K@/:vBP1~$9$Y$-$+$H$$(B $B$&LdBj$K$D$$$F!"Bh(B6$B>O$HBh(B8$B>O$K$F$h$j?<$/8!F$$9$k!#(B}$B$K$h$C$F!"<+9qFb$K%P%V%k(B $B$,H/@8(B $B$9$k!#$3$3$G@$3&6bMx$,>e>:$9$k$H$$$&30E*%7%g%C%/$,$"$C$?;~!";q6b$NBgNL0z$->e(B $B$2$K$h$C$FDL2_2ACM$,5^Mn$9$k$HF1;~$K!"%P%V%k$NJx2u$r7P$F6bM;4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$@(B $B$m$&!#$D$^$j@$3&6bMx$H$$$&30@8JQ?t$NF08~$K:81&$5$l$k;q6b0\F0$K$h$C$F!"AP;R$N(B $B4m5!$,F1;~$KH/@8$9$k$N$G$"$k(B{$B@$3&Mx;RN($NJQF0$,DL2_4m5!$H6bM;4m5!$r(B $BF1;~$K0z$-5/$3$9$H$9$kBeI=E*O@J8$O!"(BCalvo, Leiderman, and Reinhart(1993)$B!#(B}$B!#(B

$B#4(B $BEA@w8z2L(B(Contagion)



$B$"$k9q$KDL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$H$=$l$,$"$?$+$b!VEA@w!W$9$k$+$NMM$KB>$N9q$dCO0h$K(B $B$bDL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k8=>]$,4Q;!$5$l$k!#$3$&$7$?DL2_4m5!$,EA@w$9$k%a%+%K%:%`(B $B$O!"A0@b$7$?MM$J%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/DL2_4m5!%b%G%k!"<+8J$l!"Bh0l@$Be%b%G%k(B($B%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K4p$E$/DL2_(B $B4m5!%b%G%k(B)$B!"BhFs@$Be%b%G%k(B($B<+8J
4.1 $BBh0l@$Be%b%G%k$K$h$kEA@w$N@bL@(B

$BDL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$HDL2_Ev6I$,DL2_@Z$j2<$2$K(B $B$h$C$FBP93$7$h$&$HJQF00YBX@)$K0\9T$7$h$&$H<+9qDL2_$OBgI}$K8:2A$9$k$3$H$K$J(B $B$k!#DL2_4m5!$,H/@8$7$?9q$N6aNY=t9q$,$=$N9q$HF1MM$N@8;:J*$rM"=P$7$F$$$?;~!"4m(B $B5!H/@89q$NDL2_$N8:2A$O$=$N9q$N9q:]6%AhNO$N>e>:$r0UL#$7KG0W<};Y@V;z$r(B $B8:>/$5$;$k!#0lJ}$G!"DL2_4m5!H/@89q$HKG0WLL$K$*$$$F6%Ah>uBV$K$"$k6aNY=t9q$G$O(B $BAjBPE*$K<+9qDL2_$,A}2A$7!"$=$l$OCO0h$G$N9q:]6%AhNO$NDc2<$r0UL#$7KG0W<};Y@V;z(B $B$rA}2C$5$;$k!#KG0W<};Y@V;z$,Cf1{6d9T$N302_=`Hw$r>e2s$k$H(BKrugman$B$NBh0l@$Be%b(B $B%G%k$K$h$kDL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$3$H$K$J$k!#$D$^$j$3$N%b%G%k$K$h$k@bL@$G$O!"4m5!(B $BH/@89q$HKG0WE*$K6%9g>uBV$K$"$k9q$,EA@wE*$JEj5!967b$NBP>]$H$J$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$?$@$7!"$"$k9q$N0YBX@Z$j2<$2$,B>$NKG0WE*$K6%9g4X78$K$"$k6aNY=t9q$NKG0W<};Y$K(B $B1F6A$rM?$($k$?$a$K$O>/$J$/$H$bCfD94|E*$J;~4V$,I,MW$G$"$k!#$D$^$jBh0l@$Be%b%G(B $B%k$r1~MQ$7$?EA@w8z2L$N@bL@$O!"CfD94|E*$KB>9q$N0YBX%l!<%H$K1F6A$rM?$($kB&LL$H(B $B$7$F9MN8$9$Y$-$b$N$G$"$j!"0l9q$N0YBXK=Mn$,$?$@$A$KB>$N0YBX%l!<%H$K1F6A$rM?$((B $B$k>l9g$NEA@w8z2L$r@bL@$9$k$b$N$H$7$F$OBEEv$G$O$J$$!#(B

4.2 $BBhFs@$Be%b%G%k$K$h$kEA@w$N@bL@(B

$B0lJ}!"DL2_4m5!H/@88e!V$?$@$A$K!WB>$N6aNY=t9q$X8:2A05NO$,GH5Z$9$k8z2L$r!"LH@U(B $B>r9`$N$D$$$?0YBXAj>l@/:v$,9T$o$l$k$3$H$r;XE&$9$kBhFs@$Be%b%G%k$N1~MQ$9$k$3$H(B $B$G@bL@$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$3$l$O$D$^$j!"3F9q4V$N%^%/%m7P:Q@/:v!&7P:Q4D6-$NN`;w(B $B@-$r860x$H$9$kEA@w8z2L$G$"$k!#(B

$B$"$k9q$,8GDjAj>l@)$rJ|4~$7$?$H$-!"B>$N6aNY=t9q$NCf1{6d9T$,F1MM$N9TF0$r:N$k$@(B $B$m$&$HEj;q2H$,M=A[$9$l$P!"BhFs@$Be%b%G%k$K=>$C$F!"LH@U>r9`$H$7$F$N@/I\$N0YBX(B $B@Z$j2<$2$X$N%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$,9b$^$k$3$H$K$J$k!#B>$NCf1{6d9T$,8GDjAj>l@)$rJ|4~(B $B$7$?;~!"$"$k$$$ODL2_@Z$j2<$2$r9T$C$?;~$K!"$=$N9q$HF1MM$N6bM;@/:v$r:N$k$+$I$&(B $B$+$OEj;q2H$,$=$N9q$KBP$9$k;}$DN`;w@-$K0MB8$9$k!#(B $B$^$?!"6aNY=t9q$,9q:]6%AhNO$r0];}$9$k$?$a$KNY?M5gK32=@/:v$r:N$k!"$D$^$jDL2_@Z(B $B$j2<$2$N%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r;}$D$HEj;q2H$,M=A[$9$k$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$=$N;~!"4m5!H/@8(B $B9q$HKG0WE*$K6%9g>uBV$K$"$k9q$,$=$N%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:Ey$HL54X78$KEj5!967b$NBP(B $B>]$H$J$jF@$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$^$?JL$N;kE@$+$i!"$"$kCf?4E*$J9q$NDL2_$KBP$7$F6aNY=t9q$,$=$l$>$l$N<+9qDL2_$r(B $B$Z%C%0(B $B$7$F$$$k>uBV$K$*$$$F!"Cf?49q$NMx;RN(>e>:Ey$N30E*%7%g%C%/$,H/@8$9$k$H!"8GDj0Y(B $BBXAj>l@)$r0];}$9$k$?$a$K6aNY=t9q$bF1MM$KMx;RN($r>e>:$5$;$M$P$J$i$J$$!#$7$+$7(B $BMx;RN(>e>:$,$=$l$i$N6aNY=t9q$K$H$C$F9%$^$7$/$J$$1F6A$rM?$($k$3$H$,M=A[$5$l$k(B $B;~!"$=$l$^$GCf?4E*$J9q$KBP$7$F0YBX%l!<%H$r8GDj$7$F$-$?6aNY=t9q$O0YBX%l!<%H$r(B $B@Z$j2<$2$k!"$"$k$$$OJQF00YBX%l!<%H$X0\9T$9$kEy$N%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r;}$D$3$H$K$J(B $B$k!#$3$l$i$,Ej5!2H$K$h$C$FM=A[$5$l$k$H!"Ej5!2H$O8=:_$N8GDj0YBXAj>l$r0];}$G$-(B $B$J$$2DG=@-$,9b$$$HF'$s$@9q$KBP$7$FEj5!967b$r$+$1$k!#$D$^$j%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:(B $B$HL54X78$KDL2_4m5!$,O":?E*$KH/@8$9$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$3$N$h$&$K!"DL2_D4@0$r9T$C$?9q$H7P:Q9=B$$d6bM;@/:v$,!J$"$k$$$O9qL15$7$-DL2_4m5!$,$"$?$+$b(B $BEA@w$9$k$+$N$h$&$K6aNY=t9q$X9-$,$k62$l$,$"$k!#(B

4.3 $B6bM;%Q%K%C%/$HN.F0@-4m5!$K$h$kEA@w$N@bL@(B

$B$^$?!">e5-$7$?6bM;%Q%K%C%/$,9q:]E*$KO":?$9$k$3$H$G9q:]E*N.F0@-$NO":?$NNX$,CG(B $B@Z$i$l$FDL2_4m5!$NEA@w$,=V;~$KH/@8$9$kB&LL$b$"$k!#$D$^$j!"7h:Q%7%9%F(B $B%`$rDL$8$FO":?E*$KH/@8$9$k6d9To6d9T$OC;4|$G;q6b$rLL$7$F$$$k!#$3$&$7$?6d9T$N4pK\E*5!G=$G$"(B $B$kK~4|JQ495!G=$O!";q;:$HIi:D$NK~4|9=B$$rJQ49$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$FD94|E*$K;q;:$r8G(B $BDj$9$k1?MQ$r7y$&309qEj;q2H$KBP$7$FN.F0@-;q;:$rDs6!$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#FC$K%$%s(B $B%I%M%7%"!"4Z9q!"%?%$$N;09q$G$OC;4|$GH!#(B}$B!#$D$^$j$3$N;~!"$3$N;~!"2?$i$+$N30E*%7%g%C%/$K$h$C$F(B $B309qEj;q2H$,0l5$$K$h$-$r0z$-=P$9(B $B;~!"<+$i$N;q;:$rN.F02=$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$J$$6bM;5!4X$ON.F0@-ITB-$K4Y$k$3$H$K$J(B $B$k!#6bM;5!4X$KBP$9$kLL$7$F$$$k9q:]E*$JEj;q2H(B $B$,B>$N6aNY=t9q$N;T>l$K$*$$$FH`$i$N%]%8%7%g%s$rN.F02=$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$FBP1~$9$k(B $B$H!"B>$N6aNY=t9q$K

$B#5(B $B$J$<4m5!$OM=B,$5$l$J$+$C$?$N$+(B



$B%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$rFCD'$E$1$k;vl$,:#2s$NMM$J4m5!$NH/@8$rM=B,$7$F(B $B$$$J$+$C$?$3$H$G$"$k!#%"%8%"7P:Q$NH/E8$,;qK\$HO+F/$NEjF~$K$h$k$b$N$G$"$j@8;:(B $B@-$N8~>e$,H<$o$J$$$b$N$G$"$k$H$7!"$$$:$l$O?jB`$9$k1?L?$K$"$k$3$H$r;XE&$7$?M-(B $BL>$J%/%k!<%0%^%s$NO@J8(B{Krugman(1994)$B!#(B}$B$O!"K\?M$bG'$a$k$H$*$j(B {Kruguman(1998b)$B!#(B}$B!"%"%8%"7P:Q$,!V?jB`!W$9$k$3$H$rM=A[$7$?$b$N$G$"(B $B$j!"7h$7$F8=$C$F!"%"%8%"7P:Q$N9b@.(B $BD9$,@8;:@-$rH<$o$J$$BgNL$N;qK\Ej;q$N7k2L$G$"$C$F!":#2s$NDL2_4m5!$O$=$N8B3&$,(B $BO*Dh$7$?$N$@$H$$$&!V%"%8%"7P:Q@.D9$N8B3&!WE*$J5DO@$O!":#2s$NDL2_4m5!$r@bL@$9(B $B$k$b$N$H$7$FE*$r30$7$?$b$N$G$"$m$&!#(BPark(1996)$B$ONc30E*$K$b:#2s$N4m5!$rM=A[$7(B $B$?$,!"$=$&$7$?8+J}$,;T>l$N0lHLE*$J8+J}$G$"$C$?8@$&$3$H$O$G$-$J$$!#$=$NM}M3$O(B $B
$B$^$:!";T>l$N4m5!$KBP$9$kG'<1$rI=$90l$D$N;XI8$K?76=7P:Q=t9q$N7P:Qe>h$;6bMx(B(interest rate premium, risk premia)$B$,5s$2$i$l$k$@(B $B$m$&!#$b$7;qK\$,2aEY$KN.F~$7;T>l$,$=$l$K$D$$$F$N4m5!46$r6/$a$l$P>e>h$;6bMx$,(B $B>e>:$9$kH&$G$"$k!#$7$+$7%"%8%"4m5!$ND>A0$^$G$=$&$7$?>e>h$;6bMx$N>e>:$O4Q;!$5(B $B$l$F$$$J$$(B{Cline and Barnes(1998)$B$N8&5f$K$h$l$P!"El%"%8%"=t9q$N>e>h(B $B$;6b(B $BMx$O4m5!0JA0$K$O$`$7$m!VDc2
$B$^$?3JIU$15!4X(B(credit rating agencies)$B$K$h$kElFn%"%8%"=t9q$ND94|:DL3!J$D$^(B $B$j9q:D!K$N3JIU$1$r8+$k$3$H$G$bEv;~;T>l$,4m5!$rM=B,$7$F$$$J$+$C$?$3$H$r3NG'$9(B $B$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#?^I=#X$O4m5!H/@8D>A0(B(1996$B!"(B1997$BG/(B)$B$H4m5!H/@8D>8e(B(1997$BG/(B12$B7n(B) $B$N!"%`!<%G%#!<%:(B(Moody$B!G(Bs)$B$H%9%?%s%@!<%I!&%"%s%I!&%W%"!]%:(B(Standard and Poor $B!G(B s)$B$K$h$kElFn%"%8%"=t9q$N9q:D$N3JIU$1$r<($7$?$b$N$G$"$k!#$3$l$i$,<($9DL$j!"%?(B $B%$$,8GDjAj>l@)$rJ|4~$9$kD>A0$N(B1997$BG/(B6$B7n$^$G!"DL2_4m5!$rHo$C$?ElFn%"%8%"=t9q(B $B$N3JIU$1$ONI9%$"$k$$$OCfN)E*(B(positive, stable)$B$G$"$k!#$3$&$7$?l$r%"%8%"7P:Q$KBP$7$F3Z4QE*$K$5$;$?MW0x$G$"$k$HF1;~$KEv;~$N;T>l(B $B$N%"%8%"$KBP$9$k3Z4Q@-$rD>@\H?1G$7$F$$$k$H$b8@$($h$&!#(B1997$BG/(B12$B7n$K$O4m5!$r7P(B $B83$7$?$I$N%"%8%"=t9q$KBP$7$F$b3J2<$2$,9T$o$l$F$$$k$,!"$3$l$O4{$KH/@8$7$?(B (1997$BG/(B7$B7n(B)$B4m5!$rDIG'$9$k7A$G9T$o$l$?$b$N$G$"$j!"$3$N3J2<$2$,2>$K%"%8%"DL2_(B $B4m5!$r0-2=$5$;$?MW0x$K$O$J$C$?$H$7$F$b4m5!@-$,9b$^$C$F$$$k$3$H$rM=B,$7$?$b$N(B $B$G$OE~Dl$J$$$HCG8@$G$-$k!#$3$&$7$?
5.1 $B;T>l$,4m5!$rG'<1$G$-$J$+$C$?M}M3(B

$B!!$G$O$J$<;T>l$O4m5!$rG'<1$G$-$J$+$C$?$N$G$"$m$&$+!#(B

$B!!@\Ej;q$N3d9g$,B?$$$?$aN.F0@-4m5!$K4Y$k4m81@-$,(B $B>/$J$$!"(B(3)$BCfFnJF$KHf$7$FH!#(B}1994$BG/$KH/$7$?%a%-%7%3$N%Z%=4m5!$N:](B $B$K!">-Mh$NB;<:%j%9%/$r>/$7$G$b:o8:$5$;$k$?$a$K?76=;T>l7P:Q=t9q$+$i;qK\$r0z$-(B $B>e$2$k05NO$,$+$+$C$?!#Ev;~$NCfFnJF4m5!$O!"L\3P$7;~7W$N%Y%k$NMM$JLr3d(B(Wake up call)$B$r2L$?$7!"?76=7P:Q=t9q$K@x:_$9$kIT0BDjMW0x$rEj;q2H$,:F(B $B::Dj$9$k5!2q$H$J$C$?$N$G$"$k!#$=$N1F6A$OEl%"%8%"=t9q$K$b5Z$s$@$,!"lBgI}2e$2Ey$NMM!9$J@/:vBP1~$K$h$C$F>h$j@Z$C$?(B $BItJ,$,5s$2$i$l$k!#r7o!J%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k(B $B%:!K$,CfFnJF$N$=$l$KHf$Y$F!VAjBPE*$K!WNI9%$@$C$?$3$H$G$"$k!#6qBNE*$K$O!"(B (a)1980$BG/Bh$NCfFnJFDL2_4m5!$N:]$KCf?4E*MW0x$G$"$C$?9q2H$N:b@/@V;z$,%"%8%"=t(B $B9q$G$OBg$-$JLdBj$G$O$J$+$C$?$3$H!"(B(b)$B%$%s%U%lN($,$I$NElFn%"%8%"=t9q$G$bDc(B $B$+$C$?$3$H!"(B(c)$BCyC_N($,Dc2<4pD4$K$"$C$?CfFnJF$N%1!<%9$HBP>HE*$K%"%8%"=t9q$G(B $B$O30;q$KMj$i$J$/$F$b9bEY$N7P:Q@.D9$r2DG=$H$9$k9b$$9qFbCyC_N($r5-O?$7$F$$$?$3(B $B$H!"(B(d)$B302_=`Hw9b$,A}2C$7$F$$$?$3$H(B{$B%$%s%I%M%7%"!"4Z9q!"%?%$!"%U%#(B $B%j%T%s!"%^%l!<%7%"$N(B5$B%+9q$G$O7P>o<};Y$N@V;z$r>e2s$k;qK\<};Y$N0\F0(B($B9u;z(B)$B$,B3(B $B$$$?$3$H$+$i!"302_=`Hw3[$NA}Bg$,?J$s$@!#?^I=(B7$B$r;2>H!#(B}$B!"(B(e)$BElFn%"%8%"=t9q$O(B $BCfFnJF=t9q$N$h$&$K:D(B $BL3%j%9%1%8%e!<%k!J:DL37+$j1d$Y!K$r7P83$7$?$3$H$,L5$$$?$a!":DL3JV:QG=NO$KBP$9(B $B$k?.Mj$,CfFnJF$KHf$Y$FAjBPE*$K9b$+$C$?$3$H!"Ey$G$"$k!#$D$^$j!"(B(1)$B:F::Dj$5$l(B $B$?%"%8%"7P:Q$,CfFnJF7P:Q$KHf$7$FAjBPE*$KNI9%$J>r7o$G$"$C$?$3$H!"$^$?!"(B(2)$BDL(B $B2_2<$205NO$r@/:vE*$K>h$j@Z$C$?%"%8%"=t9q$N@/:v$KBP$9$k?.Mj$,H/@8$7$?$3$H!"$3(B $B$l$i(B2$B$D$,Ej;q2H$N%"%8%"7P:Q$KBP$9$k3Z4QO@$K7R$,$C$?$H9M$($i$l$k!#(B

$B!!(B $B$^$?%"%8%"7P:Q$KBP$9$k3Z4QO@$K4XO"$7$F!"Ev;v9q$N@/I\$H(BIMF$B$,%"%8%"CO0h$N6b(B $BM;%7%9%F%`$N9=B$E*LdBj$r8+H4$/$3$H$,$G$-$J$+$C$?$3$H$,;XE&$5$l$F$$$k(B {$BGr0f(B(1998)$B!#(B}$B!#%?%$!&%$%s%I%M%7%"!&4Z9q$G$O!"A0=R$7$?$h$&$K6bM;%7(B $B%9%F%`$NF)L@@-$KLdBj$,$"$C$?$?$a!"@/I\$,@53N$J>pJs$N3MF@!&4FFD!&4IM}$r9T$&Lr(B $B3d$r40A4$K2L$?$;$J$+$C$?!#$=$&$7$?6bM;%7%9%F%`$N9=B$E*$JLdBj$r@/I\$,GD0.$9$k(B $B$3$H$,:$Fq$G$"$C$?$HF1;~$K!">e5-$7$?%"%8%"7P:Q$KBP$9$k3Z4QO@$r@/:vEv6I<+?H$,(B $B;}$C$F$*$j$7$+$k$Y$-@/:v$N\:Y$J>pJs$rF~pJs$N7gG!$d;T>l$N(B $B3Z4QO@$KN.$5$l$FE,@Z$J=u8@$r9T$&%3%s%5%k%?%s%H$H$7$F5!G=$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$J$+$C(B $B$?$N$G$"$k!#$^$?!"(BIMF$B$NJ,@O\:Y$K$D$$$F$OGr0f(B(1998)$B!"(B30$B%Z!<%8$r(B $B;2>H!#(B}$B!"(BIMF$B$K$*$$$F6d9TItLg$N9=B$LdBj$r8!F$$9$k:]$K!"ItLgJLB_IU$1$dITNI:D8"(B $B$N>\:Y$JJ,N`$O9T$o$l$:$KL14VItLg$*$h$S8xE*ItLg$H$$$&6K$a$F$*$*$^$+$JJ,N`$K(B $B$h$C$F5DO@$5$l$F$$$k!#9q:];qK\<};YI=$b6K$a$FD94|!&Cf4|!&C;4|$H$$$C$?$*$*$^$+(B $B$JJ,N`$G$7$+:n@.$5$l$F$$$J$$!#$^$?D4::!&J,@O$O9qC4Ev%(%3%N%_%9%H$N:[NL$K$^$+(B $B$5$l$F$*$j!"(BIMF$B2CLA9q6&DL$N%,%$%I%i%$%s$,B8:_$7$F$$$J$$!#$=$&$7$?6bM;ItLg$N(B $B7rA4@-$KBP$9$k%_%/%m$ND4::$O$`$7$m@$3&6d9T!J(BIBRD$B!K$K$h$C$F
$B0J>eMWLs$9$k$H!";T>l$,4m5!$rG'<1$7$F$$$J$+$C$?$3$H$NM}M3$K$O(B(1)$BCfFnJF$HHf(B $B$7$F%"%8%"=t9q$N%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$NNI9%$5$,:]N)$C$?0Y$K;T>l$d@/I\<+?H$N4V$K(B $B$b3Z4QO@$,L"1d$7$?$3$H!"(B(2)$B$^$?!"@/I\$d(BIMF$B$,4m5!$rAa4|$KG'<1$7E,@Z$J7Y9p$rH/(B $B$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$J$+$C$?$3$H!"Ey$,5s$2$i$l$h$&!#(B

5.2 $B72=09TF0(B(Herding)

$B$$$^$^$G;T>l$,$^$C$?$/DL2_4m5!$NH/@8$rM=B,$G$-$J$+$C$?$H$$$&A0Ds$G5DO@$r?J$a(B $B$F$-$?!#$7$+$7$b$7;T>l$,Hs8zN($J9TF0$r:N$k;~!"4m5!$NH/@8$rM=B,$7$J$,$i$b$"$?(B $B$+$b0MA3$HJQ$o$i$L9TF0$r$H$j$D$E$1$k2DG=@-$,$"$k!#Bh0l@$Be%b%G%k$bBhFs@$Be%b(B $B%G%k$b309q0YBX;T>l$,!V8zN(E*$G$"$k!W!"$D$^$j0YBX;T(B $B>l$N%W%l%$%d!<$,MxMQ2DG=$J$9$Y$F$N>pJs$rMxMQ$7$F<+8J$N8zMQ$r:GBg$+$9$k$h$&$K(B $B9TF0$9$k$3$H$rA0Ds$H$7$F$$$k!#$7$+$78=l$,$=$N$h$&$K8zN(E*$G$J$$2DG=@-(B $B$b$"$k!#;T>l$,Hs8zN($G$"$k$H2>Dj$7$?$H$-4m5!H/@8$K4X$7$F9MN8$9$Y$-$J$N$O!V72(B $B=89TF0(B(Herding)$B!W$J$I$NMW0x$G$"$k!#72=89TF0$H$O!"B>?M$HF1$8;v$r$9$k72=8$N9T(B $BF0$,;T>l$G$NGd$jGc$$$NJQF0$rBg$-$/$9$k$b$N$G$"$k!#Nc$($P(BShiller(1989)$B$O!"(B 1987$BG/Be$N>Z7t;T>l$N3t2A5^Mn$N860x$rD4::$7!"L14VEj;q2H$,3t<0$rGd5Q$7B3$1$?M}(B $BM3$,C1$K!VCMCJ$,2lA4BN$K9-$,$C$F$$$?$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$J$<$3$&$$$C$?72=89TF0$,H/@8$9$k$N$@$m$&$+!#$=$l$O!"%P%s%I%o%4%s8z2L(B (Bandwagon effect)$B$NB8:_$K$h$C$F@bL@$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#%P%s%I%o%4%s8z2L$O!">C(B $BHq$N30It8z2L$N0l(B $BNc$G!"8D?M$N>CHq$,B>$N?M!9$N>CHq9TF0$K1F6A$5$l!"3'$HF1$8J*$r>CHq$9$k$3$H$r9%(B $B$`;~$K5/$-$k8=>]$G$"$k!#D>46E*M}2r$N0Y$K!"Nc$($P0J2<$NMM$J>u67$rA[Dj$7$h$&(B {$B0J2<$NNc$($O(BKrugman(1998)$B$N@bL@$K0M5r$7$F$$$k(B}$B!#(B

$B0l?M$N;q;:2H#A$O%?%$@/I\$N3UN=$?$A$H8rM'$,$"$k!#$b$&0l?M$N;q;:2H#B$O%?%$$N6b(B $BM;5!4X$NFbIt>pJs$KDL$8$F$$$k!#$^$?;q;:2H#C$O%?%$$NITF0;:;T>l$NF08~$K>\$7$$!#(B $B;q;:2H(BA$B$,M'?M$G$"$kBg?C$+$i%?%$$N7P:QF08~$K4X$7$FHa4QE*$J>pJs$rJ9$-%P!<%D$r(B $BGd$j$O$8$a$?$H$9$k!#;q;:2H(BA$B$,%P!<%D$rGd$C$F$$$k;v$rJ9$$$?;q;:2H(BB$B$O!"$?$H$(<+(B $BJ,$N;}$C$F$$$k%?%$$N6bM;5!4X$K4X$9$k>pJs$,%?%$7P:Q$N@h9T$KBP$7$FCfN)E*$G$"(B $B$k!"0?$$$O!"pJs$rpJs$,!Jl$N>pJs$,6K$a$F3Z4QE*$G$"$C$?$K$b(B $B4X$o$i$:%P!<%D$rGd$j=P$9$+$bCN$l$J$$!#$3$N$h$&$J(BBandwagon effect$B$K$h$C$F!"$"(B $B$kFCDj$N;q;:2H$NF@$?6K$a$F:3Kv$J>pJs$,309q0YBX;T>lA4BN$r2a>j$KH?1~$5$;$k2DG=(B $B@-$,$"$k!#(B{$B%P%s%I%o%4%s8z2L$,0YBXJQF0Aj>l$N?6$l$r2a>j$K$5$;$k$3$H$r(B $B5DO@$7$?J88%$K$O!"(BKehoe and Chari(1996)$B$J$I!#(B}$B!#(B

$B0J>e$N5DO@$rF'$^$($Fl$,DL2_4m(B $B5!$NH/@8$rM=B,$7$F$$$?$H$7$F$b!"B?$/$NEj;q2H$O4m5!H/@8$K$O4X?4$,L5$/!"B>$N;T(B $B>l4X78$N4X78l$,4m5!@-$,G'<1$5$l;O$a$??76=7P:Q;T>l$K$*$$$F$b0MA3$H$7$F4m(B $B5!$rM=B,$7$F$$$J$$$+$NMM$J9TF0$r:N$k$3$H$,@bL@$G$-$k$G$"$m$&!#(B

5.3 $B2]Bj!'DL2_4m5!$NM=B,2DG=@-$K$D$$$F(B

$B4m5!$,M=B,$5$l$J$+$C$?$H$O8@$C$F$b4m5!$rM=B,$9$k$+$NMM$JF0$-$r<($7$?;XI8$b(B $B$($P302_=`Hw$N8:>/$d@/I\$N:b@/@V;z$NA}Bg2=!"(B $B$^$?!"9qFb?.MQ$N@.D9N($J$I$,4m5!H/@8$N%?%$%_%s%0$K4X$7$F@h9T;XI8$K$J$j$&$k$3(B $B$H$r;XE&$7$?!#$^$?BhFs@$Be%b%G%k$K=>$($P!"7P>o@V;z$NA}Bg2=$de>:!&M"=P$N?-$S$NDcLB$d<:6HN($N>e>:Ey!"6!5k%7%g%C%/$K4X$9$k$"$i$f$k;XI8$,L1(B $B4V$NM=A[$rJQ2=$5$;!"DL2_4m5!H/@8$N2DG=@-$r9b$a$k$3$H$r8+$?!#$^$?DL2_4m5!$NEA(B $B@w$K4X$9$k>O$G?($l$?$h$&$K!"7P:Q9=B$$d9qL15$l9g<+9q$NDL2_4m5!$OB>$N9q$NDL2_4m5!H/(B $B@8$K$h$C$FEA@w$7$F$/$k$N$G!"<+9q$N%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$N$_$rCm;k$7$F$$$?$N$G$O(B $BM=B,IT2DG=$G$"$k!#B>9q$N7P:Q%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$NF08~$K$bCm0U$7$F$*$/I,MW$,$"(B $B$k!#(B

$B$3$l$i$N;XI8$O9qFb%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$H8GDj0YBXAj>l$H$N%.%c%C%W$K$h$C$F%$%s%P(B $B%i%s%9$,3HBg$7$D$D$"$k$3$H$r<($9$b$N$G$"$jDL2_4m5!$NH/@82DG=@-$,9b$^$C$F$$$k(B $B$3$H$r65$($F$/$l$k=EMW$J;XI8$G$"$k$G$"$k$,!"$=$l$@$1$r8+$k$@$1$G$ODL2_4m5!H/(B $B@8$N2DG=@-$,9b$^$C$F$$$k$3$H$r@-3J$KM=B,$G$-$J$$$3$H$r%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$O<($7(B $B$?!#$^$?!"$=$l$i$N;XI8$K$D$$$F$O@dBPE*$J4m81EY$r7hDj$9$k$3$H$,Fq$7(B $B$$$H$$$&LdBj$b$"$k!#(B

$BNc$($P!"%"%8%"=t9q$O4m5!$ND>A0$^$Ge>:$,8+$i$l$?$,!"$=$N(B $B>e>:$NEY9g$$$OCfFnJF$N$=$l$KHf$Y$F2:$d$+$G$"$C$?!#$^$?%?%$$d%^%l!<%7%"$G$O7P(B $B>o<};Y@V;z$,Hs>o$K9b$+$C$?$,!"%$%s%I%M%7%"$d4Z9q$N$=$l$HHf3S$9$l$PDc$+$C$?$H(B $B$b8@$($k!#Ej;q2H$O$=$l$i$rHf3S$7$?>e$G$h$jK>$^$7$$;XI8$r;}$DCO0h$X$H;qK\$r0\(B $BF0$5$;$k$@$m$&!#$@$H$9$l$P!"0lBN$I$N%l%Y%k$^$G7P>o<};Y@V;z$,A}2C$9$l$P4m81$J(B $B%l%Y%k$H8@$($k$N$+$H$$$C$?LdBj$,H/@8$7$h$&!#(B

$B$3$l$i$NEAE}E*$J;XI8$N$_$KMj$j$9$.$F$O$J$i$J$$$3$H$r%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$O6571E*$K(B $B<($7$?!#0l9q$N7P:Q>uBV$dBP30%]%8%7%g%s$N;}B32DG=@-$rH=CG$9$k$?$a$K$O!"C10l$N(B $B%b%G%k$K0M5r$7$?%^%/%m7P:Q;XI8$@$1$G$O$J$/!"L14V6bM;5!4X$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$dIT(B $BF0;:!&3t2A$N%P%V%k!"$^$?;qK\N.F~$N9=@.$J$I$"$i$f$k7P:Q;XI8$r>\:Y$KGD0.$9$k$3(B $B$H$,I,MW$G$"$k!#$3$l$i$N;XI80J30$K$b5^7c$JC;4|BP30
5.4 $B4m5!H/@8$N0z$-6b(B

$B%"%8%"=t9q!JFC$K%?%$!&%$%s%I%M%7%"!&4Z9q!K$OBh0l@$Be%b%G%k$N4m5!H/@8>r7o$r(B $BK~$?$7$F$$$?!#$7$+$7!"CfFnJF=t9q$h$j%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$,NI9%$G$"$k$H$$$&3Z4Q(B $BE*8+DL$7$K$h$C$F4m5!@-$,8+F($5$l$F$$$?$3$H!"$^$?$O4m5!@-$K5$IU$$$F$$$F$b%P%s(B $B%I%o%4%s8z2LEy$K$h$C$FEj;q2H$,Ej;q@h$NA*9%$rJQ$($J$+$C$?$3$H!"$J$I$K$h$C$F;q(B $BK\$O9qFbN.F~$7B3$1$?!#5UE>$7$F;qK\$,N.=P$7;O$a$?M}M3$K$O!"Ej;q2H$K%"%8%"=t9q(B $B$N4m5!@-$rFMA3G'<1$5$;!"Ej;q@h$H$7$FE,3J$+$I$&$+:F::Dj$5$;!";qK\$r5UE>N.=P$5(B $B$;$k2?$i$+$N!V$-$C$+$1!W(B(triggering events, wake-up call)$B$,$"$C$?$H9M$($i$l(B $B$k!#$-$C$+$1$H$J$k;v7o$OMM!9$J$b$N$,%j%9%H%"%C%W$G$-$k$,!"
(1) $B6d9T$NGKC>!'FC$K%?%$$G$O$$$o$f$k%U%!%$%J%s%9%+%s%Q%K!<(B(FC){$B%U%!(B $B%$%J%s%9%+%s%Q%K!<$OHsMB6bl$d%*%U%7%g%";T>l$+$i;q6b$rD4(B $BC#$7!"M-2A>Z7tEj;q!"Z7tB_=P$7!"=;Bp%m!<%s!"3t<0Ej;q$rL\E*$H$7$?%^!<%8(B $B%s%m!<%s$J$I$G;q6b1?MQ$r9T$&!#$7$d$9$$1?L?$K$"$C(B $B$?!#(B}$B$NITNI:D8"$,A}Bg2=$7$?$3$H$,=EMW$J$-$C$+$1$H$J$C$?!#(B1997$BG/(B3$B7n$K%U%!%$%J(B $B%s%9%+%s%Q%K!<:GBg&6H6d9T$N%@%$%@%L(B $B6d9T$H9gJ;$r;n$_$?!#$3$N7W2h$,L@$i$+$K$J$k$H%?%$$N6bM;%7%9%F%`IT0B$,9-$,$j!"(B $B$=$l0J9_%P!<%D$O=y!9$KGd$i$l;O$a$?!#(B

(2) $BBg4k6H$NE];:!'FC$K4Z9q$K$*$$$F:bH6$N7P1D4m5!$,L@$k$_$K$J$j7P:Q$N@h9T$-IT(B $B0B$,9-$,$C$?!#(B

(3) $B@/<#E*IT0BDj!'%?%$$d4Z9q$G$O4m5!D>A0$K@/8"$KF0$-$,$"$j4m5!D>8e$K$O@/8"$,(B $BJQ$o$C$F$$$k!#%$%s%I%M%7%"$G$O%9%O%k%HBgE}NN$N7r9/IT0B@b$,IQHK$G$"$C$?!#$3$&(B $B$7$?@/<#E*IT0BDj@-$b@h9T$-IT0B$K9W8%$7$?2DG=@-$,$"$k!#(B

(4) $BDL2_4m5!$NEA@w8z2L!'%?%$$GH/@8$7$?4m5!$,%&%'!<%/%"%C%W%3!<%k$H$J$jB>$NCO(B $B0h$G$bDL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$N$G$OL5$$$+$H$$$&IT0B$,ElFn%"%8%"=t9qA4BN$KL"1d$7(B $B$?!#(B

(5) IMF$B$N5_:Q%W%m%0%i%`!'(BIMF$B$N5_:Q%Q%C%1!<%8$NCf$K$OITE,@Z$J@/:v$,4^$^$l$F$$(B $B$?$3$H$bMM!9$JO@J8$K$F;XE&$5$l$F$$$k(B{IMF$B$NBP1~$K$D$$$F$N9M;!$O5DBj(B $B$+$i30$l$k$N$GK\9F$G$O9T$o$J$$!#(BIMF$B$NBP1~$NBEEv@-$K$D$$$F$NK.J8J88%$K$ONc$((B $B$P>.IM(B(1998)$B$dGr0f(B(1998b)$B$J$I!#(B}$B!#FC$K:b@/0zDy$a@/:v$r2!$7IU$1$O99$J$k

$B#6(B $BEl%"%8%"$X$NBgNL;qK\N.F~$N860x(B



$BEl%"%8%"$X5^7c$K;qK\N.F~$7$?GX7J$K$O9qFbE*$JMW0x$d30@8E*MW0x$J$IJ#?t$NMW0x$,$"$k!#0J2<H!#(B}$B!#(B

6.1 $B9qFb7P:Q@/:v$KBP$9$k?.Mj46(B

$B$^$:!"El%"%8%"7P:Q$NNI9%$J7P:Q%Q%U%)!<%^%s%9$+$i$/$kEl%"%8%"7P:Q$X$N?.Mj46$,(B $B5s$2$i$l$k$@$m$&!#FC$K!"9b$$7P:Q@.D9N($K$b4X$o$i$:>CHql$N?.MjEY$,9b$^$C$?$3$H$+$i;qK\$,5^7c$KN.F~$7$?B&LL$,$"$k$N$G(B $B$"$k!#(B{Sachs and Radelet(1998)$B$,;XE&$9$k$h$&$K!"%a%-%7%3$H4Z9q$,$$(B $B$:$l$b(BOECD$B$X$N2CLA$r2L$?$7$?D>8e$KDL2_4m5!$K8+Iq$o$l$F$$$k;v$@$?$k6bM;;T>l$N@0Hw$H;qK\9q$O9qFb%^%/%m7P:Q$N0BDj2=!"6bM;5,@)$N<+M32=!"<+M3KG0W9q$O6&$K!V;}B3IT2DG=$J;qK\BgNLN.(B $BF~!W(B(a euphoric inflow of capital that could not be sustained)$B$r7P83$9$k$3$H$H$J$C(B $B$?!#$3$&$7$?0UL#$G(BSachs$BEy$O%"%8%"4m5!$r(B(Crisis of success)$B$H8@$&$3$H$,$G$-(B $B$k$H;XE&$7$F$$$k!#(B}$B!#(B

$B!!$3$&$7$??.Mj46$HF1;~$K!"9a9A$dBfOQ$J$I$N?76=7P:Q=t9q$GDB6b%3%9%H$,9b$^$C$?(B $B$3$H$J$I$+$i!"FC$KD>@\BP30Ej;q$N%"%8%"=t9q$X$NN.F~$,5^3HBg$7$?!#$?$@$7D>@\Ej(B $B;q$K$D$$$F$O(B $B$=$N@-e5^7c$JN.=P$O5/$3$j$($:!"$^$?$C$F%"%8%"DL2_(B $B4m5!$N
6.2 $B%b%i%k%O%6!<%I(B

$B;qK\$,BgNL$K9qFbN.F~$9$k$H$$$&$3$H$O!"9qFb$N6bM;5!4X$*$h$S4k6H$,BP30l@)$K$h$k(B $B0YBX%j%9%/$N>/$J$5$HF1;~$K%b%i%k%O%6!<%I$,2L$?$7$?B&LL$r5s$2$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B $B6qBNE*$K$O!"@/I\$K$h$C$F6d9T$,5_:Q$5$l$k$3$H$,0EL[$NN;2r$H$J$C$F$$$?$3$H$,Ld(B $BBj$G$"$k!#@/I\$K$h$C$F$=$NIi:D$,J]>Z$5$l$F$$$k6bM;5!4X$,$7$P$7$P%b%i%k%O%6!<(B $B%ILdBj$r0z$-5/$3$9$3$H$O!"%"%a%j%+$K$*$1$kCyC_B_IUAH9gGKC>$KE57?E*$J$h$&$K!"(B $BNI$/CN$i$l$?6571$G$"$k!#@/I\$K$h$C$F:DL3IiC4$rJ]>Z$5$l!"$+$D@/:vEv6I$K$h$k4F(B $BFD!&4F;k5,@)$,==J,$GL5$$(B (Over-guaranteed and under-regulated)$B6bM;5!4X$O7k2L$H$7$F7P:QA4BN$KHf$7$F2a(B $B>j$JEj;q$r0z$-5/$3$9(B{$B$3$NE@$r>\@b$7$?O@J8$K$O(BMcKinnon and Pill(1996)$B$J$I!#(B}$B$3$H$,;XE&$5$l$F$$$k!#$D$^$j%b%i%k%O%6!<%I$,5/$-$k$H2a>jEj(B $B;q$K$h$C$F;q;:2A3J$,5^F-$7;q;:%P%V%k$,H/@8$9$k!#H?BPJ}8~$K;q;:2A3J$,5^Mn$9$k(B $B$H$,6bM;5!4X$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$O0-2=$9$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B$D$^$j%b%i%k%O%6!<%I$O%P%V%kH/@8$K$h$C$F6bM;4m5!$rH/@8$5$;$k860x$G$"$k$HF1;~(B $B$K!"IT:N;;$J;v6H$d;v6H$N<:GTEy$K$h$C$FH/@8$7$?B;<:$r30;q$K$h$C$FOE$&;Q@*$r=u(B $BD9$5$;$?MW0x$G$"$k!#$^$?%j%9%/0&9%E*(B(risk loving)$B$K$J$C$?9qFb$N6bM;5!4X$*$h(B $B$S4k6H$,0YBX%j%9%/$N%X%C%8$r=EMW;k$7$J$/$J$C$?$3$H$b;XE&$9$Y$-$G$"$k!#(B

6.3 $B@-5^$J6bM;4KOB(B

$B<+M32=$NH!#(B}$B!#%?%$$r;O(B $B$a$H$9$kElFn%"%8%"=t9q$,;qK\0\F0$r<+M32=$9$k:]$K!"$=$N%9%1%8%e!<%k$,@-5^$K2a(B $B$.$?E@$b5^7c$KC;4|;qK\$rN.F~$5$;$?860x$N0l$D$K5s$2$i$l$k$@$m$&!#K-$+$J@x:_@.(B $BD9NO$rM-$9$k!J$"$k$$$OM-$9$k$H;T>l$KG'<1$5$l$F$$$k!K9q$,!"$3$l$^$G5,@)$7$F$-(B $B$?Hs5o=;e$K=R$Y$?$h$&$K!"6bM;;T(B $B>l$,L$H/C#$GITB[2=$G$-$J$$!"0?$$$O%W%k!<%G%s%7%c%k5,@)$,L$=O$GITE,@Z$J6bM;Cg(B $B2p$,0Y$5$l%b%i%k%O%6!<%I$,H/@8$9$kEy$9$k$H!"%P%V%k$,H/@8$9$k!#E57?E*$J0l$D$N(B $BNc$H$7$F!"Nc$($P%P%s%3%/%*%U%7%g%";T>l(B(BIBF)$B$N%_%9%f!<%9$,5s$2$i$l$k!#$3$N;T(B $B>l$N@_CV$K4X$7$F%?%$@/I\Ev6I$N0U?^$O!"7P>o@V;z$rOE$&0Y$N30;q$NN.F~$rB%$9$3$H(B $B$@$H9M$($i$l$k$,!"$3$N0B0W$K30$N;qK\$KMj$k@/:v$,!"Cf2<0L6bM;5!4X$N3$30$+$i$N(B $B;q6bD4C#$X$N2aEY$N0MB8$r0z$-5/$3$7$?$H9M$($i$l$k!#(BBIBF$B;YE9$N%U%k%V%i%s%A>:3J(B $B$K$"$?$C$F$O!"3F9T4V$G6HL3jN.F0@-$*$h$SITF0;:%V!<%`$N860x$G$"$C$?$H;XE&$5$l$F$$$k(B {$BF|Ln(B(1998)$B$r;2>H!#(B}$B!#$3$N$h$&$J9qFb$N@/:vE*MW0x$+$iH/@8$9$k5^7c$J(B $B9q:];qK\N.F~$rKI$0$?$a$K$O0BDjE*$J9qFb%^%/%m7P:Q4D6-$r0];}$9$k$3$H$,IT2D7g$G(B $B$"$j!"$=$N$?$a$K$O:D7t;T>l$NDl$N@u$5$d6bM;%7%9%F%`$NL$@.=O$5$J$I$NH/E8ES>e9q(B $B$KE57?E*$JLdBj$NB8:_$rA0Ds$H$7$F!";qK\0\F0$N<+M32=$r!VA2?JE*$K!W9T$&$H$$$C$?(B $B@/:vE*G[N8$,I,MW$G$"$k!#(B

6.4 $B30@8E*MW0x(B

$B!!0J>e$"$2$F$-$?MW0x$O$9$Y$F9qFb$N@/:v>e$NLdBj$G$"$C$?!#$7$+$79qFb$N7P:Q4D6-(B $B$HL54X78$K;qK\$,N.F~$9$k$3$H$bM-$j$&$k!#$=$l$O.9q$K$*$$$F$O!"@$3&Mx;RN($NDc2l6bMx(B(LIBOR)$B$H$N3J(B $B:9$,!"(B1990$BG/BeA0H>$G$O(B11%$B$K$bC#$7$?!#$^$?%$%s%I%M%7%"$G$bF13J:9$OF1;~4|$K(B15% $B$K$bC#$7$?(B($BGr0f(B1998a)$B!#(B}$B!#(B(B)$B$^$?(B1994$BG/$KH/@8$7$?%a%-%7%3$N%Z%=4m5!$K:]$7$F(B $BB?3[$N;qK\$,CfFnJF$+$iElFn%"%8%"$K(B $BB`Hr$7$F$-$?;v$J$I!"30@8E*(B(exogenous)$B$KH/@8$7$?$H$P$C$A$jE*$J;qK\N.F~$bMW0x(B $B$N0l$D$K5s$2$i$l$k!#(B

$B:D7t;T>l$,L$H/C#$@$HITB[2=@/:v$,8z2L$rH/4x$G$-$:$K%$%s%U%l05NO$H$J$j!"@h$K=R(B $B$Y$?%b%i%k%O%6!<%I$N8z2L$HF1MM%P%V%k7P:Q$rH/@8$5$;$k$G$"$k!#(B

6.5 $B;ve$N%I%k8GDjAj>l@)(B

$B@)EYE*$JLdBj$H$7$F!"D9G/%?%$@/I\$,$3$@$o$jB3$1$F$-$?<+9qDL2_$G$"$k%P!<%D$NBP(B $B%I%k%Z%C%0@/:v$,5s$2$i$l$k(B{$BDL2_%P%9%1%C%H$N9=@.Hf$N7hDj$K4X$7$F!"(B 1984$BG/(B11$B7nEv=i$O%?%$$Ne>:$9$k$3$H$K(B $B$J$j!"9q:]6%AhNO$NLL$+$i%?%$$K$H$C$FITMx$J6ILL$H$J$C$?!#$=$3$G%P%9%1%C%H$N9=(B $B@.Hf$r$=$l$^$G$NKG0WNL$N2C=EJ?6Q$+$i!"$h$j%I%k$N9=@.Hf$N9b$$KG0W7h:QDL2_NL$N(B $B2C=EJ?6Q$K@/:vE*$KJQ99$7$?!#$3$l$K$h$C$F%I%k$N9=@.Hf$O(B90$B%Q!<%;%s%H6a$/$J$j!"(B $B%P!<%D$O(B $B%I%k$K6/$/O"F0$9$k!";ve$NBP%I%k8GDj0YBX@)$H$J$C$?!#(B}$B!#$3$N@/:v$O0YBX(B $BAj>l$N0BDj$rj$J3$30;qK\p$NE,@Z$J6b(B $BM;@/:v$Ne$2$kEy$N%$(B $B%s%U%l@/:v$,O$G@bL@(B $B$7$?DL$j$G$"$k!#(B

6.6 $B$^$H$a(B

$B0J>e$r$^$H$a$k$HCO0h$G$N(B $BDL2_4m5!!K$K$h$k;qK\N.F~!"(B(2)$BFbE*MW(B $B0x!J%b%i%k%O%6!<%I!"@/:vE*$J<:GT!"8GDj0YBX@)!"30;qM%6x@/:v!"9qFb%^%/%m7P:Q@/(B $B:v$KBP$9$k9q:]E*?.Mj@-$N9b$^$j!K$K$h$k;qK\N.F~!"$N(B2$BE@$K$h$C$F2aEY$N;qK\N.F~(B $B$,$"$C$?!#$3$N$H$-6bM;;T>l$NL$H/C#$5$+$iITB[2=@/:vEy$NE,@Z$J@/:vBP1~$,M-8z$K(B $BF/$+$:$K%P%V%k$r=uD9$7$F$7$^$C$?!#$3$&$7$F%P%V%kH/@8!&Jx2u$K$h$k6bM;%7%9%F%`(B $B>e$N%j%9%/$H!"2aEY$NBP30r(B $B7o$rK~$?$96K$a$F4m81$J>uBV$K$J$C$?$H8@$($k!#(B

$B0J>e$N5DO@$+$i!"(B(1)$BAP;R$N4m5!$NAPJ}$N4m5!$KBP$7$F$=$N860xE*MWAG$G$"$k!V%b%i(B $B%k%O%6!<%I!W$H!"(B(2)$B30@8E*$JMWAG$G$"$k!V3$30Mx;RN($NDc2CO0h$G$NDB6b(B $B%3%9%H$N>e>:!W$K$h$kC;4|$*$h$SD94|$N;qK\N.F~!"$*$h$S!"(B(3)$B9qFb7P:Q$N%U%!%s%@(B $B%a%s%?%k%:$H<+9qDL2_2ACM$rP*N%$5$;Ej5!967b$N2DG=@-$r9b$a$k$=$b$=$b$N856'$G$"(B $B$k!V8GDj0YBX@)EY!W!J%I%k$Z%C%0@)!K$N(B3$BE@$,%"%8%"4m5!H/@8$K4X$7$F$OK\

$B#7(B $B%?%$$N6bM;%7%9%F%`$N9=B$LdBj(B



$B!!A0>O$G$O%"%8%"=t9q$X$N;qK\N.F~$N860x$r8+$F$-$?!#9qFbEj;qN($,9qFbCyC_N($r>e(B $B2s$C$F$$$?$K$b4X$o$i$:El%"%8%"=t9q$,;}B3E*$K7P:QH/E8$G$-$?$N$O!"$3$&$7$?30;q(B $BN.F~$K$h$C$F9qFbCyC_$NITB-J,$rOE$C$F$-$?$+$i$G$"$C$?!#<+9q$N7P:Q@.D9$r9qFbCy(B $BC_$G$O$J$/e9q$O91>oE*$KDc@.D9$r6/$$$i$l$k$3$H$K$J$k$+$i$G$"$k!#$D$^$j30;qN.(B $BF~$O9b$$7P:Q@.D9$X$HN%N&$9$k0Y$N0l$D$N%A%c%s%9$J$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B!!0lJ}$GLdBj$H$5$l$k$N$O!"9qFb$K$=$&$7$?30;qN.F~$N9T$/@h$r%b%K%?!<0?$$$O%3%s(B $B%H%m!<%k$9$Y$-9qFb6bM;%7%9%F%`$,L$@0Hw$J>uBV$N$^$^J|CV$5$l$F$-$?$3$H$G$"$k!#(B $B6bM;%7%9%F%`$,L$@.=O$G$"$k$H!"N.F~$7$?;qK\$,3t<0$dITF0;:$X$H8~$1$i$l;q;:2A3J(B $B$,$=$NM}O@CM$rBg$-$/P*N%$7$F>e>:$9$k$H$$$&$$$o$f$k%P%V%k$r@8$_=P$7$F$7$^$&$N(B $B$G$"$k!#6bM;%7%9%F%`$NL$=O@-$H$O!"6qBNE*$K$O!"9qFb$N6bM;5!4X$,==J,$J7P1D%N%&(B $B%O%&$r;}$C$F$$$J$$!"Cf1{6d9T$,6bM;%7%9%F%`$N0BDj@-3NJ]$N$?$a$N%W%k!<%G%s%7%c(B $B%k@/:v$r;J$k5!4X$H$7$F$NG$L3$r2L$?$7$F$$$J$$!"6bM;5,@)!JK!N'!K$,L$=O$G$"$k!"(B $B$H$$$C$?E@$G$"$k!#$=$&$7$?6bM;%7%9%F%`$KL$=O@-!"8e?J@-$,B8:_$9$k$HN.F~$7$?30(B $B;q$,@8;:@-$NDc$$ItLg$X$H8~$+$&2DG=@-$,$"$k!#(B

$B%?%$$G$O(B1990$BG/BeCf4|(B $B0J9_$KB?3[$NC;4|@-;q6b$,3$30$+$iN.F~$7$?$,!"$3$N;q6b$,ITF0;:Ej;q$d>CHqj$J3HBg$J$IHs@8;:E*$J6bM;3hF0$KMxMQ$5$l!"F19q$K$O6d9T$N@_N)%i%C%7%e$,H/@8$7$?(B{$B%?%$$K$*$1$k6d9T$N;YE9?t$r<($9?^I=(B10$B!"$*$h$S%?%$$N>&6H6d9T$NM;;q@hFbLu$r<($9?^I=(B12$B$r;2>H!#Ev;~%?%$$G$O6d9T$N;YE9?t$,5^7c$K3HBg$7$F$*$j!"$^$?$=$NM;;q$N$&$AITF0;:$X8~$+$&3d9g$,3HBg$7$F$$$k$3$H$,$o$+$k!#$^$?%?%$$N%*%U%7%g%";T>l$G$"$k(BBIBF$B$K$FD4C#$5$l$?;q6b$N$&$ALs(B30$B%Q!<%;%s%H$OITF0;:!"%^%s%7%g%s6H$*$h$S6bM;6H$X$HN.$l$F$$$?$3$H$,$o$+$k(B($B?^I=(B12)$B!#(B}$B!#$=$N8e!"ITF0;:2A3J$,2e$2$,9T$o$l$=$l$,$^$?6bM;4m5!(B $B$rA}I}$5$;$k$H$$$&!"Bh(B3$B>O$G=R$Y$?$h$&$J6bM;4m5!$HDL2_4m5!$NAj8_:nMQ$N0-=[4D(B $B$,H/@8$7$?$N$G$"$C$?!#(B

$B0J>e$NE@$rF'$^$($F!":#2s$N4m5!$N860x$N9M;!$9$k$K$"$?$C(B $B$F!"$=$&$7$?6bM;4m5!H/@8%7%J%j%*$NCf$G0l$D$NMW0x$H$J$C$?%?%$$N6bM;%7%9%F%`$N(B $B9=B$>e$NLdBj$re$2$F$*$/I,MW$,$"$k(B{$B%?%$0l9q$r07$&$N$O!"$3$N9q$,(B $B%"%8%"7P:Q4m5!$NH/C<$H$J$C$?9q$G$"$j!"$^$?%?%$$N6bM;;T>l$,?76=;T>l7P:Q(B (emerging market economies)$B$N6bM;9=B$$H$7$FE57?E*$G$"$k$HH=CG$7$?$?$a$G$"(B $B$k!#$D$^$j%?%$0l9q$NJ,@O$G$b?76=;T(B $B>l7P:Q$N6bM;%7%9%F%`$K6&DL$9$kFCD'$G$"$j6571$H$J$kItJ,$,B?$$!#(B}$B!#0J2H$7$?!#(B}$B!#(B

7.1 $B%b%i%k%O%6!<%I(B

$BA0>O$NBh(B2$B@a$G?($l$?$h$&$K!"@/I\$K$h$k:DL3IiC4$N0EL[$"$k$$$OL@Gr$JJ]>Z$,%b%i(B $B%k%O%6!<%I$r0z$-5/$3$7!"L14V6bM;5!4X$rMF0W$K%j%9%/$N9b$$C;4|$NBP30l9g!"%j%9%/$N9b$$3t<0$dITF0;:Ej;q$HC;4|$N30;q
7.2 $B@/I\!&4k6H!&6bM;ItLg4V$KB8:_$9$kL)@\$GITF)L@$J4X78(B

$B2<0L6bM;5!4X$rITF0;:$d>CHqpJs@8;:9=B$$NOD$_$r5s$2$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#Nc$($P!"4k6H>pJs$N3+<($,Dc(B $B$$7P:Q$G$O!"6d9T$K$H$C$F$bB_IU@h$N?3::$r!V8x3+>pJs!W$K$h$C$F9T$&$3$H$,Hs>o$K(B $BFq$7$$!#$D$^$j!"6d9T$O>pJs@8;:$r%*!<%W%s$K$5$l$?>pJs$K$h$C$F$G$O$J$/!"FCDj$N(B $B?M4V4X78$K4p$E$/!VB0?M>pJs!W$X$N0MB8$K$h$C$F9T$&!#%?%$$N>l9g!"FC$K!V2Z?M!W$N(B $B%M%C%H%o!<%/$rCf?4$H$7$?>pJs@8;:$K;Y$($i$l$F6bM;3hF0$,@.N)$7$F$$$?!#$3$&$7$?(B $B>pJs@8;:9=B$$NOD$_$,;D$5$l$?$^$^6bM;<+M32=$,?J9T$7$?$3$H$,!"I,A3E*$K6bM;5!4X(B $B$N;q;:1?MQ$r$bOD$^$;$k7k2L$H$J$C$F$H8@$($k$@$m$&!#2?8N$J$i2<0L6bM;5!4X$O?.MQ(B $B>pJs$NHf3SE*CHq
7.3 $B8xE*@/:v!'6bM;5,@)$NL$=O@-(B

$B6bM;%7%9%F%`$N9=B$LdBj$N0l$D$K!"6bM;5,@)$dK!@)EY$N8e?J@-$r5s$2$k$3$H$,$G$-(B $B$k!#Nc$($P!"%$%s%I%M%7%"$NGK;:K!$OHs>o$K8E$/(B{$B;e@%(B(1998)$B!#(B}$B!"8=(B $B$K(B100$BK|%I%k$C$F6d9T$,7P1DFq$K4Y$C$?4k6H$+$iM;;q$r2s<}$9$k(B $B$3$H$OHs>o$KFq$7$/!"6d9T$O$=$N4k6H$N7P1D$,2~A1$9$k$^$GM;;q$r7QB3$9$k$3$H$rM>(B $B57$J$/$5$l$k!#(B

$B$^$?!";T>l6%Ah$r7rA42=$9$k$?$a$N%W%k!<%G%s%7%c%k5,@)$,ITE0Dl$@$C$?$3$H$b2<0L(B $B6bM;5!4X$r4m81$J;q;:1?MQ$KAv$i$;$?$3$H$H4X78$9$k!#Nc$($P!"5,LO$N>.$5$J6d9T$,(B $B;T>l$N?.G$$rF@$k$?$a$K$OBg5,LO6d9T$h$j$b9b$$<+8J;qK\HfN($rJ]$D$3$H$,=EMW$G$"(B $B$k!#$7$+$7%?%$$G$O!"2<0L6bM;5!4X$N<+8J;qK\HfN($,>e0L6bM;5!4X$N<+8J;qK\HfN($h(B $B$j$bDc$/$J$C$F$$$k$K$b4X$o$i$:;T>l$,2<0L5!4X$K?.G$$rM?$(B3$1$F$$$?!#<+8J;qK\(B $BHfN($,;T>l?.G$$N%P%m%a!<%?!<$H$7$F$N5!G=$H$7$F40A4$K5!G=$7$F$$$?$H$O8@$$Fq(B $B$/!"%j%9%/$K4X$9$k>pJs$K;T>l!&6d9TAPJ}$,F_46$G$"$C$?$H8@$($k!#$3$&$7$?%j%9%/(B $B>pJs$K4X$o$k5,@)$,4K$+$C$?!&$"$k$$$OB8:_$7$J$+$C$?$3$H$,LdBj$J$N$G$"$k!#(B

$BF1MM$K!"6bM;$N%b%K%?%j%s%05!G=$,IT:_$G$"$C$?$3$H$bLdBj$H$$$($k!#(B $BEl%"%8%"3F9q$OAju672<$G!"BgH>$N4k6H%0%k!<%W$,<+$i$N6d9T$r=jM-$9$k$h$&$K$J$j!"6d9T$O(B $BEvA3$J$,$i%0%k!<%W7ONs$X$N4k6H$XM%@hE*$KM;;q$r9T$C$?!#$3$&$7$?OD$s$@6bM;;T>l(B $B$N>u67$r%b%K%?%j%s%0(B($B4F;k(B)$B$9$kLr3d$r@/I\$bCf1{6d9T$b2L$?$7$F$$$J$+$C$?$N$G$"(B $B$k!#(B

$B6bM;%7%9%F%`$,A4BN$H$7$F0BDjE*$+$D8zN(E*$K5!G=$9$k0Y$K$O!";T>l$KHw$o$C$?7P1D(B $B4F;k5!G=$d8xE*Ev6I$K$h$k4FFD!&5,@)$rDL$8$F6d9T7P1D

$B#8(B $B5^7c$JC;4|;qK\N.F~05NO$K$I$&@/:vBP1~$9$Y$-$+(B



$B!!0J>e!"%"%8%"=t9q$K;qK\$,5^7c$K9qFbN.F~$7$F$/$k860x$H$J$C$?MW0x$H$=$l$i$r%P(B $B%V%k7P:Q$X8~$1$F$7$^$C$?6bM;%7%9%F%`$N9=B$LdBj$H$r@0M}$7$F$-(B $B$?!#$7$+$7A0>O$GF1MM$K3NG'$7$?$h$&$K!"5^7c$J;qK\N.F~$OI,$:$7$b9qFb$N@/:v<:GT(B $BE*$JMW0x$K$h$C$F$N$_0z$-5/$3$5$l$k$o$1$G$O$J$/!"3$30Mx;RN($N5^7c$JDc2<(B {$BFC$K!"F|K\$ND94|$K$o$?$kDc6bMx>uBV$,3$30Mx;RN($NDc2<$H$7$FEl%"%8%"(B $B=t9q$X$N;qK\N.F~$N0l0x$H$J$C$?MWAG$,6/$$!#(B}$B$d3$30(B $B$NB>$N?76=7P:Q=t9q$G$NDL2_4m5!H/@8$J$I$K$h$C$F30@8E*$KH/@8$9$k>l9g$b$"$j$&(B $B$k!#5^7c$J;qK\N.F~$O
(1) $B5^7c$J;qK\N.F~$O9qFb7P:Q$N%P%V%kE*MWAG$r=uD9$7!"6bM;4m5!H/@8$N0l0x$K$J(B $B$k!#Bh(B3$B>O$G=R$Y$?7PO)$rDL$8$F6bM;4m5!H/@8$,DL2_4m5!$rH/@8$5$;$k2DG=@-$,$"(B $B$k!#(B

(2) $B;qK\N.F~$,l9g!";qK\$N5UE>N.=P$K$h$C$FBh(B3$B>O(B3$B@a$G(B $B?($l$?$h$&$J%7%J%j%*$G!"6bM;4m5!$HDL2_4m5!$H$$$&!VAP;R$N4m5!!W$rH/@8$5$;$k2D(B $BG=@-$,$"$k!#(B

(3) $B8GDjAj>l@)$N2<$G$N;qK\N.F~$K$h$k%$%s%U%l05NO$O!"%7%c%I!<0YBXAj>l$r8:2A$5(B $B$;$k!#L>L\0YBX%l!<%H$H%7%c%I!<0YBXAj>l$H$N%.%c%C%W$,Ej5!967bH/@8$N2DG=@-$r9b(B $B$a!"Bh0l@$Be%b%G%k$N4m5!$,H/@8$9$k2DG=@-$r9b$a$k!#(B

(4) $B8GDjAj>l@)$N2<$G$N;qK\N.F~$K$h$k%$%s%U%l05NO$O!"o<};Y$,@V;z2=$9$k!#(B $B;:=PNL%7%g%C%/8z2L$K$h$C$FBhFs@$Be%b%G%k$N4m5!$,H/@8$9$k2DG=@-$,9b$^$k!#(B

$B!!=>$C$F!"@/:vEv6I$O!"9qFbE*$K$O;qK\N.F~05NO$,9b$^$j$D$D$"$k;~$K$O$=$l$r4:$((B $B$FB%?J$9$k$h$&$J@/:v!JNc$($P%?%$$N@-5^$J(BBIBF$B3+@_!K$r:N$i$J$$$3$H!"$^$?9qFbE*(B $B@/:v$H$OL54X78$K30@8E*$KH/@8$7$?;qK\N.F~05NO$KBP$7$F$O$7$+$k$Y$-@/:vBP1~$K(B $B$h$C$F%$%s%U%l05NO$rKI$0$Y$-$G$"$k!#$G$O$=$&$7$?30@8E*$KH/@8$7$?5^7c$J;qK\N.(B $BF~05NO$K;/$5$l$D$D$"$k=t9q$,:N$k!V$7$+$k$Y$-@/:vBP1~!W$r$I$&9M$($k$Y$-$@$m$&(B $B$+!#;qK\N.F~$KBP$7$F$"$k9q$,:N$k@/:v$K$O0J2<$NL\E*$,$"$k$@$m$&!#(B

(A) $B9qFb$N2a>jN.F0@-H/@8$rKI$0$?$a$N@/:v(B
(B) $B;qK\N.F~$=$N$b$N$rM^@)$5$;$h$&$H$9$k@/:v(B
$B0J2<$K=t@/:v$K$D$$$F$N$=$l$>$l$=$ND9C;$r@0M}$7$?>e$G!"K>$^$7$$@/:vBP1~$N$"$j(B $B$+$?$r9M$($?$$(B{$B0J2<$NE83+$O
8.1 $B;qK\
$B!!>e$K5s$2$?(B(1)$B!"(B(2)$B$N$9$Y$F$NLdBj$KBP$9$kBP=h$H$7$F!"9q:]E*$J;qK\0\F0(B $B$KBP$7$Fl$N%k!<%k$K=>$C$F9qFb$KEj2<$5(B $B$l$?;qK\$Nl$N?.Mj$rCx$7$/B;$M(B $B$k!#$^$?%5%C%/%9(B(1998)$B$,;XE&$9$k$h$&$K!"$$$C$?$sB?3[$N;q6b$,9qFb$KF~$k$H$=$l(B $B$r(B $B9qFb$KJD$89~$a$F$*$/$3$H$OD94|E*$K$OFq$7$/!"$=$ND94|E*8z2L$b5?Ld$G$"$k!#$=$&(B $B$7$?0UL#$G;qK\N.=P5,@)$O@/I\$N@/:v$KBP$9$k;T>l$N?.Mj@-$r=E;k$9$k$N$G$"$l$P6K(B $BNOHr$1$k$Y$-A*Br;h$G$"$m$&!#(B}$B!#$3$l$K$ONc$($P!"(B(1)$BHs5o=;
$B!!(B(A)$B$^$:!"5,@)$rF3F~$7$F$bL14V7P:Q];q;:!J6d9TMB6b$J$I!K$r2sHr$7$F!"3t<0$dEj;q?.Bw$X$H$=$N;qK\(B $BN.F~$N7PO)$r0\$9$@$m$&!#$^$?!";qK\$N5UE>N.=P$r62$l$k@/I\$,C;4|;qK\N.F~$r5,@)(B $B$7$h$&$H$7$F$b!"Ej;q2H$N9qFb$X$N;qK\Ej2<$,2L$?$7$FD94|E*$JL\E*$J$N$+!"Ej5!L\(B $BE*$J$N$+@/I\$,F05!$K$^$GF'$_9~$s$GD4$Y$k$3$H$O$G$-$J$$!#$3$l$i$N;T>l$NF0$-$K(B $BBP$7$F!"@/I\$dDL2_Ev6I$,$=$l$>$l4F;k!&BP1~$7$F$$$/$3$H$K$O8B3&$,$"$k!#$^$?!"(B $B5,@)$O:G=*E*$K$OJB9T;T>l!J0G;T>l!K$,H/C#$9$k2DG=@-$b$"$jK>$^$7$/$J$$7k2L$r@8(B $B$`2DG=@-$b$"$k!#=>$C$F!";qK\
$B!!(B(B)$B$^$?;qK\N.F~$K$b$^$7$$$b$N$HK>$^$7$/$J$$$b$N$,:.9g$7$F(B $B$$$k$N$,8=$^$7$/$J$$!#Nc$($P!"@/I\$+(B $B$i$_$FEj5!$,L\E*$@$H9M$($i$l$k>Z7tEj;q$N$h$&$J7ABV$N;qK\N.F~$b!"9qFb$NEj;q2H(B $B$K$H$C$F$OD94|J]M-$,Ej;q$NL\E*$G$"$k2DG=@-$b$"$k!#$=$&$G$"$k$H$7$?$i!"7k2L$H(B $B$7$F$O$^$7$$;qK\N.F~$r5,@)$K$h$C$F<:$C$F$7$^$&$3$H$K$J$k!#F((B $B$2B-$NAa$$C;4|;qK\$K$D$$$F$O5,@)$7D>@\Ej;q$H$$$C$?D94|E*Ej;q$OM%6x$9$k$H$$$C(B $B$?Ej;qM=Dj4|4V$K1~$8$?A*BrE*$J;qK\5,@)$b!";T>l$O(B(A)$B$G=R$Y$?$h$&$KMM!9$J9)IW(B $B$r6E$i$7$F;qK\$r0\F0$5$;$h$&$H$9$k$@$m$&!#$=$&$7$?;T>l$NF0$-$KBP$7$F!"@/I\$N(B $B4F;k5!G=$K$O8B3&$,$"$k!#(B

$B!!!J(BC$B!K;qK\8e$K6[5^E*$K@/I\$,;\9T$9$k$H$$$&%1!<%9$,(B $BB?$$!#$=$N>l9g!"5,@)F3F~%W%m%;%9$,AF;($G967bE*$J%1!<%9$,IQHK$G$"$j!";T>l$N@/(B $BI\$N@/:v$KBP$9$k?.G$$NDc2<$K$h$C$F$+$($C$FDL2_$H3t2A$N2&(B $B6H6d9T$KBP$7$F!"(B200$BK|%j%s%.$rD6$($k%j%s%.Gd$j%9%o%C%WZ7t$rA}(B $BI}$5$;!"99$J$kDL2_2ACM$H3t2A$N2.>>(B (1998)$B!#(B}$B!#(B

$B!!(B $B!!$7$+$7!";qK\0\F05,@)$K8z2L$N8B3&$dLdBjE@$,$"$k$+$i$H$$$C$F!"$9$Y$F$N;qK\0\(B $BF05,@)$rGS$9$Y$-$@$H$$$&$$$o$f$k!V%o%7%s%H%s!&%3%s%;%s%5%9!W(B{$B%o%7%s(B $B%H%s!&%3%s%;%s%5%9$H$O!"(BIMF$B$NK\It$,$"$k%o%7%s%H%s$G7A@.$5$l$k9q:]6bM;$N@/:v(B $B1?1D$r;X$9!#$=$N4pK\E*$J7P:Q;WA[$O<+M3$J%b%N$H%^%M!<$Nl$r$H$k!#(B}$B$K$b(B $BLdBj$,$"$k!#(B $B$=$l$O!"40A4$K<+M3$J9q:];qK\0\F0$dJF9qN.$N<+M3;T>lJ|G$l86M}$rF3F~$7$F7P:Q@.D9$7$F$f$/$K$OL5M}$,$"$m$&!#;T>l86M}$K(B $BBQ$($&$k9q2H7P:Q4pAC$r:n$j>e$2$kESCfCJ3,$G$O!"4|4V8BDj$N0l;~E*A
$B!!(B $B!!$D$^$j$3$3$G$N4pK\E*7kO@$Oe$GG'(B $B$a$i$l$k$3$H$b$"$k$,!"4pK\E*$K$O$"$/$^$G4|4V8BDj$NC;4|E*!&6[5^E*A
8.2 $B:b@/0z$-Dy$a@/:v(B

$B!!IT67$r@/:vE*$K0z$-5/$3$9!"$D$^$j:b@/$r0z$-Dy$a$k@/:v$b9MN8$9$Y$-$G$"$k!#:b(B $B@/0zDy$a@/:v(B{$B6qBNE*$K$O@G6b$r0z$->e$2$kJ}K!$H8x6&;v6HEy$N@/I\;Y=P$r(B $B:o8:$9$kJ}K!$N#2$D$,$"$k!#(B}$B$K$OAm<{MW$rM^@)$9$k$3$H$G;qK\N.F~$K$h$k%$%s%U%l(B $B05NO$d%P%V%k=uD9$H$$$&@\$N8z2L$r;}$D$b$N$G$O$J$$$,!"(BIS$B6J@~$r:82
$B$?$@$7!"L14VItLg$N<{MWD62a$K$h$C$F9b6bMx$,@8$8$F$$$k>l9g!"@G6b(B $B$N0z$->e$2$O>-Mh$N@8;:NO$N8~>e$5$;$&$kL14VEj;qEy$N=EMW$J7P:Q@.D9$X$N%A%c%s%9(B $B$r;&$7$F$7$^$&2DG=@-$,$"$k!#F1MM$K@/I\$N;Y=P:o8:$O!"7P:QH/E8$K$H$C$F@8;:E*$J(B $B:b@/;Y=P9`L\$r:o8:$7$F$7$^$&2DG=@-$,$"$k!#=>$C$F!":b@/0zDy$a@/:v$O!"2aEY$N:b(B $B@/;Y=P$K$h$k9b6bMx$,;qK\N.F~$N860x$G$"$k>l9g$K8B$j!"
$B$=$NB>$K$b@/I\;Y=P:o8:$NLdBjE@$H$7$F$O!"@/<#E*%U%#!<%8%S%j%F%#$NE@$,5s$2$i$l(B $B$k(B $B$@$m$&!#$D$^$jBe5D@)L1.$5$;$k@/:v$O!V3+H/FH:[$N@5Ev@-!W(B $B$rMI$k$,$9MW0x$H$J$k$?$aMF0W$K$O
$B:b@/0z$-Dy$a@/:v$N$=$NB>$NLdBjE@$O!"6bM;@/:v$Nl$X$N9q:D6!5k$,8:>/$9$k!#$H$$$&$3$H$O!":D7t;T>l$NH/E8$K$H$C$F$OD94|E*$KK>$^(B $B$7$$$H$O8@$($J$$!#C;4|E*LdBj$H$7$F$O!":b@/@/:v$N5!F0@-$NLdBj$,5s$2$i$l$h$&!#(B $B$D$^$j!":b@/0zDy$a@/:v$,8z2L$rH/$9$k$^$G$K$O>/$J$/$H$bH>G/0J>e$N;~4VE*%:%l(B (time lag)$B$,$"$k!#$3$&$7$?;~4VE*%:%l$,$"$k$?$a$K!":b@/0zDy$a@/:v$O6[5^;~$K$*(B $B$1$kC1FH$G
8.3 $BITB[2=@/:v(B

$B!cDL>o$NITB[2=@/:v!d(B

$B!!;qK\N.F~$,B3$/$H<+9qDL2_$K7QB3$7$?A}2A05NO$,$+$+$k!#8GDj0YBX@)EY$r0];}$9$k(B $B0Y$KCf1{6d9T$O7QB3$7$F<+9qDL2_$rC;4|6bM;;T>l$KJ|=P$7B3$1$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$0Y!"(B $B2a>jN.F0@-$,H/@8$9$k!#$=$l$O6bM;4KOB@/:v$r:N$C$F$$$k$N$HF1MM$N8z2L$H$7$F8=$l(B $B$k!#$D$^$j%$%s%U%lN($,9b$^$j!"(B(3)(4)$B$NB&LL$+$iDL2_4m5!$rH/@8$5$;$k2DG=@-$r9b(B $B$a$k$G$"$m$&!#DL>o!"Cf1{6d9T$O%^!<%1%C%H%*%Z%l!<%7%g%sEy$rDL$8$F2pF~$NITB[2=(B (sterilization)$B$r$7$F%$%s%U%l05NO$r4KOB$5$;$h$&$H$9$k(B{$BNc$($P!"%"%a(B $B%j%+$NCf1{6d9T$G$"$k%"%a%j%+O"K.=`Hw6d9T(B(FRB)$B$G$O!"300O;T>l2pF~$KH<$&Bg35;n(B $B;;$NA}8:$O<+F0E*$K40A4$KITB[2=$5$l$k$3$H$K$J$C$F$$$k!#(B1$B2/%I%k$N%I%kGd$j2pF~(B $B$r$7$?;~!"(BFRB$B$O$=$l$KBP1~$7$F:bL3>J>Z7t$r8x3+;T>l$K$FGd5Q$7;T>l$+$i(B10$B2/%I%k(B $BJ,$NN.F0@-$r5[<}$9$k!#(B}$B!#ITB[2=@/:v$OL14V6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$r0-2=$5$;$k$3(B $B$H$b$J$/!"$^$?;q;:G[J,$rOD$aFCDj$N7P:Qe>:$7!"5U$K;qK\N.F~$rB%$7$F$7$^$&$H$$$&B&LL$r;}$C$F(B $B$$$k!#(B

$B!!(B $B!!ITB[2=@/:v$,9qFb6bMx$r>e>:$5$;$F$7$^$&$H$$$&B&LL$rM}2r$9$k$?$a$K!"ITB[2=$r(B $BH<$&0YBX2pF~$,$I$N$h$&$K0YBX%l!<%H$H9qFb6bMx$K1F6A$rM?$($k$N$+$K$D$$$F$b$&>/(B $B$7>\$7$/?($l$F$*$-$?$$!#Nc$($P!"2M6u$NEg9q%1%$%*%&6&OB9q$NCf1{6d9T$,BP%I%k$N(B $B8GDjAj>l$r0];}$9$k$?$a$K(B5$B2/%f%-%A(B{$B%1%$%*%&6&OB9q$NDL2_C10L!#(B}$B$N%f%-(B $B%AGd$j2pF~$r$9$k%1!<%9$rA[Dj$7$h$&(B{$B?^I=(B14$B$r;2>H!#(B}$B!#$3$N2pF~$K$h$C$FCf1{6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H(B $B$K$*$$$F!";q;:9`L\$NBP30;q;:(B(FA)$B$HIi:D9`L\$N;TCf6d9TMB6b3[$,$=$l$>$l(B5$B2/%f%-(B $B%A$E$DA}2C$9$k!#$=$l$OA4BN$H$7$F$D$^$j(B5$B2/%f%-%A$N%O%$%Q%o!<%I%^%M!<$NA}2C$G(B $B$"$k!#%^%M!<%5%W%i%$$r0lDj$KJ]$A$?$$DL2_Ev6I$OITB[2=@/:v$r$7$F8x3+;T>lA`:n(B $B!JGd$j%*%Z!K$K$h$C$F@/I\:D7t(B5$B2/%f%-%AAjEv$r;TCf6d9T$KGd5Q$9$k!#$3$NA`:n$K(B $B$h$C$F!"Cf1{6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$N;q;:9`L\$G$"$k9qFb?.MQ(B(DC)$B$r(B5$B2/%f%-%A8:>/(B $B$5$;!"F1;~$KIi:D9`L\$G$"$k;TCf6d9TMB6b3[$r(B5$B2/%f%-%A8:>/$5$;$k!#$3$NITB[2=$K(B $B$h$C$F%O%$%Q%o!<%I%^%M!<$NAm3[$O0lDj$KJ]$?$l$k$,!"%O%$%Q%o!<%I%^%M!<$r9=@.$9(B $B$kBP30;q;:$H9qFb;q;:$NHfN($OJQ2=$9$k!#$D$^$jCf1{6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H>e$G$O!"(B $BBP30;q;:$,(B5$B2/%f%-%AA}2C$79qFb;q;:$,F13[8:>/$7$F$$$k!#F1$8;v$rN"JV$7$F8@$&(B $B$H!"L14VItLg4*Dj>e$G$O!"Ej;q2H$NJ]M-$9$k309qDL2_7z$F;q;:$,(B5$B2/%f%-%AAjEv8:>/(B $B$7!"<+9qDL2_7z$F;q;:$,F13[A}2C$9$k!#$b$79qFbDL2_7z$F;q;:$H309qDL2_7z$F;q;:$,(B $B40A4$KBeBXE*$G$"$k$J$i!"L14VItLg$K$*$1$kEj;q2H$N%]!<%H%U%)%j%*$N9=@.Hf$O7P:Q(B $B$N%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$K2?$i1F6A$rM?$($k$3$H$OL5$$$@$m$&!#$7$+$7N>e>:05NO$,$+$+$k!#$3$N$h$&$K(B $BITB[2=@/:v$OD94|E*$K$O6bMx$N>e>:$rDL$8$F$=$N8z2L$,8BDj$5$l$?$b$N$K$J$k!J$"$k(B $B$$$O5U8z2L$K$J$k!K2DG=@-$,$"$k!#(B

$B!!$^$?ITB[2=@/:v$O!"!V8GDjAj>l@)!W$H!V;qK\0\F05,@)$NE1GQ!W$H$NAH$_9g$o$;$K(B $B$h$C$F;qK\N.F~$r0z$-5/$3$70W$/$9$k!#$D$^$j!"8GDjAj>l@)$G$O!"$=$l$,;}B3$9$k$H(B $B$$$&;T>l$N?.Mj$,$"$k8B$j!"0YBX%j%9%/$O%<%m$G$"$j!"$=$l$O$D$^$j9qFb30$N;q;:$,(B $B40A4$KBeBXE*$G$"$k$3$H$r0UL#$9$k!#$3$N>uBV$G%/%m%9%\!<%@!<$N;qK\0\F0$,40A4$K(B $B<+M3$G$"$l$P!";qK\$NN.=PF~$N6bMx$KBP$9$kCFNO@-$OL58BBg$K$J$j!"6O:9$N9qFb30$N(B $B6bMx:9$,@8$8$F$bB?3[$N;qK\N.F~$H$J$m$&!#$3$N$H$-!"ITB[2=@/:v$O99$J$k;qK\N.F~(B $B$r>7$-!";qK\N.F~$HITB[2=@/:v$N%9%Q%$%i%k$K$J$k2DG=@-$,$"$k(B{$BITB[2=@/(B $B:v$K$h$k6bMx>e>:$,$h$jB?$/$N;qK\N.F~$r0z$-5/$3$7$F$7$^$&7P83$K$O(B1991$BG/$N%3%m(B $B%s%S%"Ey!#(B}$B!#$3$N$H$-!";qK\0\F0$N6bMxCFNO@-$,Hs>o$K9b$$>uBV$G$O!"Bh(B3$B>OBh(B3$B@a(B $B$G3NG'$7$?!VAP;R$N4m5!!W$KH/@8$K$*$$$F6K$a$F4m81$J>uBV$G$"$k!#(B

$B!!$^$?H/E8ES>e9q$O:D7t;T>l$,>.5,LO$+$DL$H/C#$G$"$k>l9g$,B?$$$?$a!"Cf1{6d9T$,(B $BGd5Q!&J|=P$9$k:D7tEy$r==J,5[<}$G$-$:7k2L$H$7$F6bMx$,>e>:$7$d$9$$$H$$$&B&LL$b(B $B;XE&$G$-$k!#$3$NE@$K4X$7$F!"@/I\$,@/:vE*$KITB[2=8z2L$r==J,H/4x$G$-$k!J$D$^$j(B $B>.5,LO$N;T>l2pF~$G$O6bMx$,>e>:$7$K$/$$!K:D7t;T>l$N@0Hw$H?<2=$r?d?J$5$;$k$3$H(B $B$G!"D94|E*$K$O!"$"$kDxEY2r7h$9$k$+$b$7$l$J$$!#0lJ}!"ITB[2=@/:v$K$h$C$F5[<}$G(B $B$-$k%O%$%Q%o!<%I%^%M!<$N3[$O!"$=$N;~E@$GCf1{6d9T$,J]M-$7$F$$$k:D7t$N3[$K$h$C(B $B$F>e8B$,Dj$a$i$l$F$$$k!#$D$^$jCf1{6d9T$,J]M-$9$k;T>l@-:D7t$N3[$rD6$($k;qK\$,(B $BN.F~$7B3$1$k>u67$K$*$$$F$O$3$NITB[2=@/:v$O7QB3E*$KMQ$$B3$1$k$3$H$K$O8B3&$,$"(B $B$k0Y(B{$B?^I=(B15$B!"(B16$B!"(B17$B!"(B18$B$r;2>H!#?^I=(B18$B$NB@@~$OCf1{6d9T:D$rMQ$$$?ITB[2=$NDxEY$rI=$7$F$$$k!#$^$?:Y@h$O?^I=(B16$B$K$*$1$k302_;q;:3[$+$i%O%$%Q%o!<%I%^%M!<$r0z$$$?CM$G$"$k!#$3$N$h$&$J%$%s%I%M%7%"$NCf1{6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$r4Q;!$9$k$H!"F19q$O(B1995$B!"(B96$BG/$K$+$1$FITB[2=$N5,LO$,=L>.$7$F$*$jITB[2=@/:v$N8B3&$KC#$7$F$$$?$3$H$,$o$+$k!#F1MM$K%?%$$K$*$$$F$b(B94$BG/$+$i(B95$BG/$K$+$1$FITB[2=$N5,LO$,=L>.$7$F$$$k$3$H$r<($7$F$$$k!#(B}$B!"B>$N@/:v%*%W%7%g%s$rMQ$$$k$3$H$,I,MW$H$5$l$k!#$=$NB>$N@/:v$H$7$F9-5A$N(B $BITB[2=$r(B2$BE@0J2<$K9M;!$9$k!#(B

$B!c9-5A$NITB[2=(B(1)$B!';YJ'$$=`HwN($N0z$->e$2!d(B

$B!!L14V6d9T$N;YJ'=`HwN($r9b$a$k$3$H$G!"2_J>>h?t$rDc2<$5$;$F6d9T$N?.MQA}Bg$rM^(B $B@)$7e>:$rM^@)$9$k8z2L$,$"$m$&!#;YJ'=`HwN($NLdBjE@$Oe$K2]@G$H$J$k$N$G;T>l$N8zN(@-$KOD$_$r$b$?$i(B $B$9!#$3$N0UL#$G!"!VDL>o$N!WITB[2=@/:v$NJ}$,K>$^$7$$$H9M$($i$l$k!#(B(2)$B;YJ'=`Hw(B $BN(>e>:$K$h$kHqMQ$NA}2C$rB_IU$1N($N>e>:$HMB6bN($N0z$-2<$2$GOE$*$&$H$9$k!#$D$^(B $B$j6d9T$N4pK\E*5!G=$N0l$D$G$"$k;q6bCg2p5!G=$rAK32$9$k!#(B(3)$BB_IU$1N($N>e>:$rB_(B $BIU$16bMx$N>e>:$r0UL#$9$k!#9qFbB_IU$16bMx$N>e>:$O9qFb4k6H$,;q6bD4C#$9$k:]$K30(B $B9q$+$i;q6b$rD4C#$9$k%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$r9b$a$k$3$H$K$J$j!"$+$($C$F;qK\N.F~$r>7$/(B $B2DG=@-$,$"$k!#(B(4)$B;YJ'$$=`HwN($r2aEY$K9b$a$k$H!"5,@)$NLV$+$i30$l$?JB9T;T>l$d(B $B%N%s%P%s%/ItLg$NH/C#$rB%$9$3$H$K$J$k!#(B

$B!c9-5A$NITB[2=(B(2)$B!'Cf1{6d9T:D$NH/9T!d(B

$B!!Cf1{6d9T$,J]M-$9$k:D7t$rL14V6bM;5!4X$KGd5Q$9$k$H$$$&$$$o$f$k!VDL>o$N!WITB[(B $B2=@/:v$O!"ElFn%"%8%"=t9q$NMM$K:D7t;T>l$,L$H/C#$GCf1{6d9T$bBgNL$N9q:DEy$rJ]M-(B $B$7$F$$$J$$>l9g$=$N8z2L$K8B3&$,$"$k!#$=$N>l9g!"Cf1{6d9T<+?H$,:DL3>Z=q$rH/9T$7(B $B;T>l6bMx$GL14V$+$i;q6b$r5[<}$9$kJ}K!$r:N$k$H$$$&A*Br$b$G$-$k(B{$BF|K\$K(B $B$*$1$kCf1{6d9T:D$NH/9T$N7P83$O!">e$2$N;~$N$h$&$K!"L14V6bM;5!4X$K;ve$N2]@G8z2L$rM?$($k$3$H(B $B$b$J$/!"%^!<%1%C%H86M}$N;q8;G[J,$d7P:Q9TF0$rOD$a$k$3$H$OL5$$$H8@$($k!#(B

$B!!$7$+$7Cf1{6d9T:D$NH/9T$K$h$kITB[2=$K$O!">e5-$7$?!VDL>o$N!WITB[2=@/:v$HF1MM(B $B$NLdBjE@0U30$K$b$"$kLdBj$,H/@8$9$k!#$D$^$jCf1{6d9T$,:D7t$rH/9T$7$?8e!"Cf6d$N(B $B%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$K$O;q;:B&(B(assets)$B$K$O302_>Z7t$,5-O?$5$l!"Ii:D(B(liabilities)$BB&(B $B$K$OCf1{6d9T:D$,5-O?$5$l$k!#Cf1{6d9T:D$N6bMx$O302_>Z7t$N6bMx$r>e2s$k$N$,DL>o(B $B$G$"$k!#2?8N$J$i!"Ej;q2H$,5a$a$k<+9qDL2_7z$F;q;:$OI,$:$7$b>o$KCf1{6d9T:D$N$h(B $B$&$JC;4|;q;:$G$"$k$H$O8B$i$J$$$+$i$G$"$k!#$3$N$?$a!"BgNL$NCf1{6d9T:D$rC;4|$K(B $BH/9T$7$h$&$H$7$F$b;TCf>C2=$5$l$-$l$:!"%G%#%9%+%&%s%HHNGd$rM>57$J$/$5$l$k$G$"(B $B$m$&!#$3$N$?$aCf1{6d9T:D$NH/9T$K$h$C$FCf1{6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H$O0-2=$9$k$3$H(B $B$K$J$k(B{$BCf1{6d9T:D$rH/9T$9$k$3$H$K$h$kCf1{6d9T$N<}1W>e$N5U>d$K$h$kB;(B $B<:$O!V=`:b@/%3%9%H!W(B(quasi-fiscal cost)$B$H8F$P$l$k!#(B}$B!#$b$A$m$sCf1{6d9T$NLr3d(B $B$OMx1W$r5s$2$k$3$H$G$OL5$$$N$G!"%P%i%s%9%7!<%H>e$N5U>d$O$=$l$@$1$rM}M3$H$7$F(B $BCf6d:DH/9T$K$h$kITB[2=@/:v$rJ|4~$5$;$k$b$N$G$O$J$$!#$7$+$7Cf1{6d9T$N%P%i%s%9(B $B%7!<%H$N0-2=$O?<9o$JLdBj$H$7$F9q:]E*$KG'CN$5$l$F$$$k$h$&$G$"$k!#(B

8.4 $BB_=P5,@)(B

$B!!6d9TItLg$N3t!&ITF0;:$X$N2a>jEj;q$r4FFD$7M^@)$9$k5,@)F3F~$b$R$H$D$NJ}K!$G$"(B $B$k!#$=(B $B$N5,@)8z2L$OO$G3NG'$7$?$h$&$J6d9TItLg$N%b%i%k%O(B $B%6!<%I$,860x$GBP30l9g!J$D$^$j9qFb$N@/:vE*MW0x$K$h$C$F;qK\(B $BN.F~$,5/$3$C$F$$$k;~!K$K$O!"%b%i%k%O%6!<%I$rGS$9$Y$/$7$+$k$Y$-@/:vBP1~$r:N$k(B $B$H$H$b$K!"6d9T$KBP$9$k9M::!&4FFD$N6/2=$K$h$C$F3t$dITF0;:$X$N2a>jEj;q$rM^@)$7(B $B;q;:2A3J$N5^F-$rKI$.%P%V%k$rKI$0$3$H$,I,MW$G$"$k!#$3$l$OM=KIE*$J0UL#$G9T$&@)(B $B:n$G$"$k!#(B(2)$B$3$l$KBP(B $B$7$F30@8E*$KH/@8$7$?;qK\N.F~$O2a>jN.F0@-$rH/@8$5$;!"$=$NEj;q@h$,3t<0$dITF0;:(B $B$K8~$1$i$l0W$/$J$k!#$3$l$rKI$.;q;:2A3J$N5^F-$K$h$k%P%V%kH/@8$rKI$0$N$,L\E*$N(B $B;v8eE*A
8.5 $B;q6bD4C#5,@)(B

$B!!B_=P5,@)$N$h$&$JEj;qB&$N5,@)$G$O$J$/!";q6bD4C#B&$K5,@)$r2]$7$F30;qN.F~$KBP(B $B1~$9$k@/:v$b9M$(F@$k!#(B $B$=$l$O$D$^$j6d9T$N%P%i%s%9%7!<%H>e$N7rA4@-$r6/2=$r@/:vE*$K9T$&$H$$$&$3$H$G$"(B $B$k!#O(B3$B@a$NN.F0@-4m5!$+$i$/$kAP;R(B $B$N4m5!H/@8$NM=KI$KBP1~$9$k$b$N$G$"$k!#(B(3)$B9q:DEy!"0BA4@-$N9b$$;q;:$NJ]M-$r5A(B $BL3$E$1$kJ}(B $BK!!#(B(4)$B2a7c$J@/:v$H$7$F$O!";q;:$r<+9qDL2_7z$F;q;:$K8BDj$9$kJ}K!!J$3$l$OM%@h(B $BB_=P$75,@)!K!"(B(5)$B9qFbL14V6d9T$NMB6bN($*$h$SB_=PN($rD>@\E*$K@)8B$9$kJ}K!!#(B $B$3$l$iMM!9$J5,@)$d4F;k@/:v$rAH$_9g$o$;$k$3$H$G9qFbE*$JMW0x$+$i30;q
8.6 $B0YBX@Z>e$2MFG'@/:v(B

$B!!<+9qDL2_$NA}2C$rMFG'$7!"8GDjAj>l$r@Z$j>e$2$k$3$H$K$h$C$F;qK\N.F~$KBP=h$9$k(B $BJ}K!$b9M$(F@$k@/:v$G$"$k!#$=$N>l9g$NC;4|E*$J8z2L$O0J2<$NDL$j$G$"$k!#$^$:0YBX(B $B@Z>e$2$K$h$j9qFbM"=PItLg$N3hF0$,=L>.$7.$K$h$jKG0W<};Y$,@V;zJ}8~$K8~$+$&!#0lJ}!"8GDjAj>l@)$r0];}$7$h$&$H$7(B $B$FL5M}$K0YBX;T>l2pF~$9$kI,MW$,L5$/$J$k$?$a!"%O%$%Q%o!<%I%^%M!<$d302_=`Hw$OA}(B $B8:$7$J$$!#$D$^$j%O%$%Q%o!<%I%^%M!<$r%3%s%H%m!<%k$G$-$k$H$$$&%a%j%C%H$O$"$k!#(B $B$^$?!"0YBX@Z>e$2$OM"F~IJ$N9qFb2A3J$rDc2<$5$;$k$N$G!"7k2L$H$7$FItJ,E*$K9qFb2A(B $B3JA4BN$N>e>:$r$bM^$(%$%s%U%l$rM^@)$9$k$H$$$&%W%i%9$N8z2L$,4|BT$G$-$k!#$^$?!"(B $B0YBX@Z2<$2$,$7$P$7$P9T$o$l$kMM$K$J$k$H;ve$NJQF0Aj>l@)$r:NMQ$7$F$$$k>l9g$K(B $B6a$$8z2L$rH/@8$5$;$k!#$D$^$j!"JQF00YBX$N%j%9%/$,9b$^$j!"30;q$K$h$k9qFbEj;q$K(B $BBP$9$k7Y2|46$,H/@8$7Ej5!E*$JC;4|;qK\N.F~$rM^@)$9$k$+$bCN$l$J$$!#$3$N$h$&$JE@(B $B$,0YBX@Z>e$2MFG':v$N%a%j%C%H$G$"$k!#(B

$B!!$7$+$70lJ}$G!"IQHK$K$3$NJ}K!$KMj$k$H;T>l$N8GDjAj>l@)EY$=$N$b$N$KBP$9$k?.Mj(B $B$,Dc2<$7!"$=$b$=$bH/E8ES>e9q$,8GDjAj>l@)$rF3F~$9$kF05!$G$"$kItJ,(B{$BH/(B $BE8ES>e9q$,8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$9$kM}M3$K$D$$$F$OO$r;2>H!#(B}$B$r<+$iH]Dj$9$k$3$H(B $B$K$J$m$&!#$^$?6O$+$J;:=PNL%7%g%C%/BP$7$F$bIQHK$K0YBX@Z>e$2$,9T$o$l$l$P!"L14V(B $B7P:Qe$G9T(B $BF0$9$k$h$&$K$J$k$@$m$&!#$=$N>l9g!"BhFs@$Be4m5!%b%G%k$N%W%m%;%9$K=>$C$FDL2_4m(B $B5!$,<+8Je$2$,DL2_4m5!$N(B $B$-$C$+$1(B(triggering event)$B$H$J$k$3$H$bM-$jF@$h$&!#(B

8.7 $B6bM;4KOB@/:v(B

$B!!6bM;4KOB$K$h$C$F9qFb6bMx$rDc2<$5$;$k@/:v!#$3$l$K$h$C$F<+9q;q;:$NL%NO$,Dc2<(B $B$5$;$k$N$G;qK\$NN.F~05NO$r4KOB$5$;$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#$3$l$K$h$C$F(B(2)$B$NLdBjE@$+(B $B$iH/@8$9$kAP;R$N4m5!M=KI$K$O$"$kDxEY8z2LE*$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$7$+$7$?$@$G$5$(%$%s(B $B%U%l5$L#$N9qFb7P:Q$KBP$7$F!"99$J$k6bM;4KOB$O9qFb7P:Q$N%P%V%k@-$rBg$-$/9b$a(B $B$k!#$^$?%$%s%U%l$H%P%V%k7P:Q$,99$KBP30
8.8 $B9qFbM"=PItLg$KBP$9$kJd=u6b@)EY(B

$B!!FC$K(B(4)$B$NLdBj$KBP$9$k2r7h:v$H$7$F!"9qFb$NM"=PItLg$X$NJd=u6b3[$rA}2C$5$;$F(B $Bl$N?.G$$r<:$&!#9qFb$NM"=PItLg(B $B$KBP$9$k%W%i%9$N8z2L$H0l9q7P:QA4BN$N%^%$%J%9$N8z2L$H$N%H%l!<%I%*%U$r9MN8$7$?(B $B>e$G!"?5=E$K
8.9 $BK>$^$7$$@/:vBP1~$H$O(B

$B!!A0=R$7$?$,!"9qFbCyC_N($r>e2s$k9qFbEj;qN($r2DG=$H$9$k30;q$NN.F~$O!"DL2_4m5!(B $B$N2DG=@-$r9b$a$k$HF1;~$K9b$$7P:Q@.D9N($X$N%A%c%s%9$G$"$k!#FC$KCyC_N($,Dc$/e9q$,7P:Q@.D9$rL\;X$9;~!"0l;~E*$KBP(B $B30E*$Jo@V;z$NA}Bg$r0UL#$9$k!#Ev3:9q$NDL2_Ev6I$OKG0W@V(B $B;z$NA}Bg2=$rKI$4$&$H$7$F!"4h$J$K8GDj0YBX%l!<%H$r;`$^$7$/$J$$!#8GDjAj>l@)$N2<$G;qK\$,BgNL$KN.F~$9$k$H$9$k$HDL2_4m5!$,H/@8$9$k$@$m$&!#;qK\N.F~$KBP$9$k:GE,(B $B$+$DM#0l$J@/:v$OB8:_$7$J$$!#:GE,$JAH$_9g$o$;$OB8:_$9$k$+$b$7$l$J$$!#$3$N$h$&(B $B$K;qK\N.F~$KBP$9$k@/I\$HDL2_Ev6I$N@/:v$K$O!V@lLgCN<1$H7P83$,=EMW$J0UL#$r$b$D(B $B%"!<%H!J5;7]!K$NMWAG!W(B{$B2,It(B(1996)$B$+$i0zMQ!#$?$@$7!"J*2AD4@0$H0YBXAj(B $B>lD4@0$H$$$&%H%l!<%I%*%U$KD>LL$9$kCf1{6d9T$N@/:v1?1D$K4X$7$F$NJ8L.$NCf$G;H$o(B $B$l$F$$$k!#(B}$B$,5a$a$i$l$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B#9(B $B8GDj0YBXAj>l@)$K4X$9$k=tLdBj(B



$B:#$^$G!"8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$7$F$$$k$H$NA0Ds$G5DO@$r?J$a$F$-$?!#$=$7$F8GDjAj>l(B $B@)$,$=$NB8:_<+BN!"Ej5!967b$N2DG=@-$r9b$a$kMW0x$G$"$k$3$H$bBh(BX$B>O$G3NG'$7$?!#(B $B$7$+$7H/E8ES>e=t9q$NB?$/$,40A4$J8GDjAj>l@)$d8GDjAj>lE*MWAG$N6/$$%P%9%1%C%H!&(B $B$Z%C%0@)!"$^$?$O$=$l$K6a$$!V4IM}$5$l$?JQF0Aj>l@)!W$r:NMQ$7$F$$$k(B{$B?^(B $BI=(B19$B$r;2>H!#(B}$B!#$=$b$=$b$J$e9q$O8GDj0YBXAj>l@)$N7gE@$K$b(B $B4X$o$i$:$=$l$r:NMQ$9$k798~$K$"$k$N$@$m$&$+!#H/E8ES>e9q$OJQF0Aj>l@)$r:NMQ$7$F(B $B$O$J$i$J$$$N$@$m$&$+!#$b$7JQF0Aj>l@)EY$r:NMQ$9$l$P9qFb%U%!%s%@%a%s%?%k%:$H0Y(B $BBX%l!<%H$H$N4V$N%.%c%C%W$,3HBg$7$9$.$k$3$H$OL5$/$J$j!"Ej5!967b$rH/@8$5$;$kMW(B $B0x$O>/$J$/$J$j!"DL2_4m5!$O$h$jH/@8$7$K$/$/$J$kH&$G$"$k!#$H$$$&$3$H$O!"DL2_4m(B $B5!$rKI$0$?$a$N5DO@$K$*$$$F!"6bM;%7%9%F%`$N@He9q$,8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$7$h$&(B $B$H$9$kF05!$r(B2$BE@$K$^$H$a(B{$B0J2<$NJ,N`$H@bL@$K:]$7$F!"Gr0f(B(1998)$B$*$h$S(B $B9bLZ(B(1992)$B$r;2>H$7$?!#(B}$B!"8GDjAj>l@)$KJQ$o$kBeBX0F$K$O$I$N$h$&$J$b$N$,$"$k(B $B$+!"$=$l$i$NMxE@$HLdBjE@$O2?$+$r9M$($?$$!#(B

$B!!(B 9.1 $BH/E8ES>e9q$,8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$9$kM}M3(B

$BBh0l$K!"=>Mh%$%s%U%l;V8~$G$"$C$?9q$NDL2_Ev6I$,!"<+9qDL2_$rDc%$%s%U%l9q$NDL(B $B2_$K%j%s%/$9$k$3$H$G%$%s%U%lN($rM^$($k$3$H$,$G$-$k$H$$$&!"$$$o$f$k!V%$%s%U%l(B $BM^@)$NL>@<$NM"F~!W$H$$$&F05!$r5s$2$k$3$H$,$G$-$k(B{$BDc%$%s%U%l9q$NDL2_(B $B$K<+9qDL2_$r8GDj$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F%$%s%U%lM^@)$NL>@<$rM"F~$G$-$k$H$$$&0lO"$N8&(B $B5f$K$O!"(BGiovannini and Giavazzi(1989), Melitz(1988), Giavazzi and Pagano(1988)$B$J$I!#H`Ey$K$h$l$P!"2$=#DL2_@)EY(B(EMS)$B$N;22C=t9q$NDL2_Ev6I$,$=$l(B $B$>$l$N<+9qDL2_$r%I%$%D%^%k%/$K%j%s%/$5$;$F%I%$%D$N%$%s%U%lM^@)$NL>@<$rM"F~$7(B $B$h$&$H$7$?F05!$,$"$C$?$3$H$,!"(BEMS$B;22C9q4V$N@/:v6(D4$r2DG=$H$7$?!#(B}$B!#$"$k9q$,(B $BJQF0Aj>l@)$r:NMQ$7!"$=$N9q$NCf1{6d9T$,;T>l2pF~$K$h$C$F0YBX%l!<%H$r<+M3$KJQ99(B $B$9$k$3$H$N$G$-$k;~!"Cf1{6d9T$OL14V$N4|BT%$%s%U%lN($r>e2s$k%$%s%U%lN($rH/@8$5(B $B$;$?$j!"$"$k$$$OL14V7P:Ql@)$O8GDjAj>l@)$KHf(B $B$Y$F$3$N$h$&$J6bM;@/:v$r:[NLE*$KH/F0$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k$H$$$C$?MxE@$,$"$k$,!"H/(B $BE8ES>e9q$N>l9g$=$N@/:vL\I8$,J*2A$N0BDj!J%$%s%U%l$NKI;_!K$h$j$be9q$G$OCf1{6d9T$NFH(B $BN)@-$,==J,$G$J$$>l9g$,B?$$$?$a!"JQF0Aj>l@)2<$NH/E8ES>e9q$G$O:[NLE*!&3HBgE*$J(B $B6bM;@/:v$K$h$C$F%$%s%U%lN($,9b$^$k798~$K$"$k!#;T>l$,$3$&$7$?:[NLE*$J6bM;@/:v(B $B$KBP$9$kCf1{6d9T$NF05!$K5$IU$$$?;~!"@/:vJQ99$N2DG=@-$r$b8+9~$s$@>e$G7P:Q3hF0(B $B$r9T$&$h$&$K$J$j!"DB6b>e>:!&4|BT%$%s%U%lN($N>e>:Ey$,$*$3$j!"$^$9$^$9%$%s%U%l(B $BN($r>e>:$5$;$d$9$/$9$k!#$b$7Dc%$%s%U%l9q$NDL2_$K<+9qDL2_$r%j%s%/$5$;$=$N9q$N(B $B6bM;@/:v$K=>$&$3$H$rI=L@$9$l$P!";T>l$OCf1{6d9T$,%$%s%U%lM^@)$N@/:v%9%?%s%9$K(B $BJQ$o$C$?2DG=@-$,$"$k$HM=A[$7!"M=A[%$%s%U%lN($rDc2<$5$;!"%$%s%U%l2CB.$rKI$0$3(B $B$H$,$G$-$k$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B!!(B $BBhFs$K!"0YBX%j%9%/$N7Z8:$K4X$9$kF05!$,5s$2$i$l$k!#0lDj$N9q$H$NKG0Wl9g$K$O!"$=$N9q$NDL2_$H$N4V$NJQF0$r>/$J$/$9$k$3$H$G0YBX%j%9%/$,KX$IB8:_(B $B$7$J$/$J$j$=$N7k2L$H$7$FKG0Wl@)$h$j8GDjAj>l@)$NJ}(B $B$,C;4|E*$K$O.$5$/$J$C$F$$$k!#(B}$B!#FC$KH/E8ES>e9q$NB?$/(B $B$G$O0J2<$NMM$JM}M3$+$i0YBXAj>l$r8GDj$9$k$3$H$K$h$k%a%j%C%H$,Bg$-$$!#(B(1)$BFCDj(B $B$N9q!9$H$NKG0W.9q$G$"$k$?$a7P:Q$N2rJ|EY(B{$B!V7P:Q(B $B$N3+J|EY!W$K$OLL$,$"$j!"MM!9$JDj5A$N;EJ}$,$"$k$,!"$3$3$G$O(B GNP$B$K@j$a$kM"=PF~Am3[$N3d9g$H$7$F9M$($F$$$k!#(B}$B$,9b$/!"9qFb<{5k$,l$N<{5k$K5(@a@-$,$"$k!"(B(3)$B$=$l$K2C$($F!"l$K8|$_$,L5$/!"M"=PF~6Hl$,B8(B $B:_$7$J$$!"0?$$$OL$H/C#$G$"$k!#FC$K(B(1)$B$N7P:Q$N2rJ|EY$K$D$$$F!"7P:Q5,LO$N>.$5(B $B$$>.9q$O!"<+9q7P:Q3hF0$K$*$$$FB>9q$+$i$NKG0W:b$N@j$a$kHfN($,798~E*$K9b$$!#Nc(B $B$($P!">.$5$JEg9q$G$O8B$i$l$?CHq:b$rM"F~$KMj$C$F$$$k!#$3$N$h$&$J7P:Q$G!"0YBX(B $B%l!<%H$,IQHK$K$7$+$bBg$-$/JQF0$9$k$H!"<+9qDL2_$O>CHq:b$KBP$7$FB,$C$?0BDjE*$J(B $B2ACM$NJ]B8$H$7$F5!G=$7$J$/$J$k$@$m$&!#2rJ|EY$N9b(B $B$$>.9q$OBg9q$r4^$`DL2_7w$N0lIt$K$J$k$Y$-$@$H$$$&5DO@$G$"$k!#$D$^$jH/E8ES>e9q(B $B$K$H$C$F$O!"8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$9$k$3$H$K$h$k0YBX%j%9%/$rL5$/$9;v$,9qFb7P:Q$N$N(B $B0BDj2=$^$?$O9q2H$N<}F~8;$H$7$F$b=EMW$JLdBj$G$"$k!#$D$^$j$=$NE@$G$bH/E8ES>e9q(B $B$K$O8GDjAj>l@)$r:NMQ$9$k%$%s%;%s%F%#%V$,9b$$!#(B

9.2 $B8GDjAj>l@)$,5!G=$9$k>r7o(B

$B5^7c$K;q6b$,9qFb$KN.F~$7B3$1$F$*$j!"$+$D8GDjAj>l@)$r0];}$7$?$$>l9g$O!"@/I\$O(B $BITB[2=@/:v$J$I$K$h$C(B $B$F2_J>6!5k$NA}Bg$rKI$,$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#0lJ}$GH/E8ES>e(B $B9q$N:D7t;T>l$O!"$3$&$7$?8x3+;T>lA`:nEy$N8z2L$r==J,$KH/4x$5$;$k$K$OL$H/C#$K2a(B $B$.$k$b$N$G$"$k>l9g$,B?$$!#$D$^$jA4>O$G3NG'$7$?$h$&$K!"@/I\$"$k$$$OCf1{6d9T$K(B $B$h$C$FBgNL$N:D7t$,H/9T$5$l$k$H6bMx$,>e>:$799$J$k;qK\N.F~$r0z$-5/$3$7$=$N8z2L(B $B$,==J,H/4x$5$l$J$$2DG=@-$,$"$k!#==J,$JITB[2=@/:v$N8z2L$,4|BT$G$-$J$$;~!"2_J>(B $B6!5k$O2_J><{MW$r>e2s$j%$%s%U%l05NO$Oe>:$5$;$k$3$H$K$J$m$&!#(B $B$D$^$j!"8GDjAj>l@)$OCfC;4|E*$K$O$=$N0];}$,2DG=$G$"$k$,!"D94|E*$J0];}$OFq$7$$(B $B$N$G$"$k!#$^$?C;4|$K@$3&Cf$rF0$-2s$k;q6bNL$,A}Bg$9$k:#F|$G$O!"5,@)$K$h$C$F;q(B $BK\N.=PF~$r2!$(9~$`$H$$$C$?@/:v$r:N$i$J$$8B$j!"$H$j$o$18GDjAj>l@)$N0];}$OFq$7(B $B$$$b$N$H$J$C$F$$$k!#;qK\O$G?($l$?(B $BDL$j$G$"$k!#(B

$B!!H/E8ES>e9q$O8GDjAj>l@)$,$=$l<+BN$GEj5!967b$NBP>]$H$J$j$d$9$$$3$H$rCN$j$J$,(B $B$iC;4|!&Cf4|E*Au67$G$O8GDjAj>l@)$N0];}$OHs>o$KFq$7$$!#$@$+$i$3$N>O$N(B $B7kO@$O!"D94|E*$K$OC&5Q$rL\;X$9$Y$-$b$N$H$7$F8GDjAj>l@)$rB*$($k$Y$-$G$"$k!"$H(B $B$$$&$3$H$@!#C;4|!&Cf4|E*Al@)$r:NMQ$7$?>l9g$G$b!"A0=R$7$?$h$&(B $B$KA2?JE*$J6bM;<+M32=$d%W%k!<%G%s%7%c%k5,@)$*$h$S:D7t;T>l$N@0Hw$J$I$N9qFb$N@/(B $B:vE*$JMW0x$K$h$C$FBP30$K5^7c$KN.F~$5$;$J$$@/:vEXNO$,I,MW$G$"$k!#$b$7@$3&Mx;R(B $BN($N5^Dc2<$dB>$N?76==t9q$G$NDL2_4m5!$K$h$k!V$H$P$C$A$j!WE*$J5^7c$J;qK\$NN.F~(B $B$,$"$C$?>l9g$OA0$N>O$G8+$?$h$&$J@/:v%*%W%7%g%s$rAH$_9g$o$;$F%P%V%k$rH/@8$5$;(B $B$J$$$h$&$J@/:vEXNO$,I,MW$G$"$k!#(B

$B#1#0(B $BEl%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$N6571$H:#8e$N2]Bj(B



$B!!El%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$N6571$H:#8e$N2]Bj$r!"7kO@$H$7$F0J2<$N(B4$BE@$K@0M}$9$k!#(B

$BBh0l$K!"ElFn%"%8%"A40h$r4^$a$F!"?76=H/E8ES>e9q$N6bM;%7%9%F%`$r9q:];qK\l$N@0Hw$r5^$0$Y$-$H$$$&$3$H$@!#%"%8%"4m5!$N>l9g$O!"6bM;5!4X$N7P(B $B1DBNpJs8x3+$NIT==J,$5!&$=$l$KH<$&2Z?M$rCf?4$H$7$?B0?M>p(B $BJs$K$h$k>pJs@8;:!"$^$?6bM;5,@)4FFDBN@)$NITHw$d5^7c$9$.$k6bM;4KOB$K$h$k%b%i%k(B $B%O%6!<%I$N=uD9$H%P%V%k$NH/@8$J$I$,6qBNE*$KLdBj$H$J$C$?!#I,MW$J$N$O$^$:Bh0l(B $B$K!"@/I\$,6bM;5!4X$KBP$7$F!"<+NO$G;q;:!&Ii:D4IM}$r9T$($k8zN(E*$J7P1DG=NO$r?H(B $B$K$D$1$5$;$k$3$H!"$^$?2q7W4p=`$d>pJs3+<($J$I$N@)EY$r3NN)$5$;!"Ej;q2H$dMB6bpJs$rEA$($5$;$k;v$G$"$k!#6bM;%7%9%F%`$r@0Hw$77rA4$J$b$N$K$9$k$3$H$K(B $B$h$C$F!"$?$H$(5^7c$J;qK\$NN.F~!&N.=P$,H/@8$7$F$b$=$l$,D>$0$K6bM;5!4X$NB_$7=P(B $B$7$NKDD%!&=L>.$KO"F0$7$F6bM;%7%9%F%`IT0B$K$D$J$,$k$3$H$N2DG=@-$r8:>/$9$k$3$H(B $B$,$G$-$k$N$G$"$k!#$3$&$7$?G'<1$rL14V6bM;5!4X$,;}$D$?$a$K$b@/I\Ev6I$K$h$k6bM;(B $B%W%k!<%G%s%7%c%k5,@)$NAa4|@0Hw$,=EMW$G$"$k!#(B

$BBh%K$K!"C;4|;qK\$,9qFbE*$J!"$"$k$$$O30@8E*$JMW0x$K$h$C$FBgNL$+$D5^7c$K(B $B9qFbN.F~$7$D$D$"$k>l9g$K$O!"$$$/$D$+$N@/:v%*%W%7%g%s$GBP1~$9$Y$-$G$"$k$H$$$&(B $BE@$G$"$k!#$R$H$D$N%*%W%7%g%s$H$7$F!";qK\e$,$i$l$k$,!"5,@)$O(B $B$"$/$^$GC;4|E*!&6[5^E*$JAl$N?.G$$r<:$&$?$a$+$($C$FK>(B $B$^$7$/$J$$!#$^$?!"ITB[2=@/:v$r9T$&$?$a$K$O:D7t$r==J,5[<}$G$-$k@.=O$7$?;T>l$N(B $BB8:_$,A0Ds$H$J$k$,!"H/E8ES>e9q$G$O$=$&$7$?;T>l$,L$H/C#$G==J,$J8z2L$rH/4x$G$-(B $B$J$$2DG=@-$,9b$$!#D94|E*$K$O$=$&$7$?ITB[2=@/:v$N8z2L$r==J,H/4x$5$;$&$kMM$J:D(B $B7t;T>l$N@0Hw$r?J$a$k$Y$-$@$,!"C;4|E*$K$O!";qK\$NN.F~05NO$KBP$9$kBeBX0F$H$7(B $B$F!"Nc$($P!"6bM;5!4X$rG^BN$H$7$?C;4|;qK\N.F~$KBP$7$F$=$N0lDj3d9g$rK!Dj=`Hw$"(B $B$k$$$ON.F0@-;q;:$GJ]M-$9$k$3$H$r5AL3$E$1$kEy$N@/:v$,M-8z$+$D8=e$NBP30$^$7$$(B{$B%5%C%/%9(B(1998)$B$bF1MM$N;XE&!#(B}$B!#$3$NJ}K!$G!"5^(B $B7c$J;qK\N.=P$K$h$k6bM;5!4X$N%]!<%H%U%)%j%*$N0-2=$rHr$1$k
$BBh;0$K!"C;4|;q6b$N0\F0$,5pBg2=$7$D$D$"$k8=:_!"L5M}$JAj>l8GDj@)$X$N0MB8$O5"$C(B $B$FEj5!967b$NBP>]$H$J$k2DG=@-$,9b$/!"%I%k8GDjAj>l@)$N0];}$O6K$a$F:$Fq$G$+$DK>(B $B$^$7$/$J$$$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!#D94|E*$K(B $B$O!"BP307P:Ql@)$K$X$N0\9T$rL\;X$9$Y$-$G$"$k!#4{$K=R$Y$F$-$?$h$&$K!"JF(B $B%I%k$KO"F0$7$?0YBX@)EY$O!"(B1994$BG/=iF,$NCf9q?ML185$N@Z$j2<$2!&(B95$BG/H>$P$+$i$N1_(B $B0B!"$^$?%?%$9qFb$N%$%s%U%l!<%7%g%s$N?J9T$K$h$C$FI,MW@-$,9b$^$C$F$-$?@/:v$KBP(B $B$9$kL@$i$+$J@)EY>c32$H$J$C$F$$$?!#8GDj0YBX@)EY$O$3$N$h$&$KI,MW$K1~$8$F=@Fp$J(B $B6bM;@/:v$N@/:v%*%W%7%g%s$NI}$r<+$i69$aHs8zN($G$"$k$HF1;~$K$=$NB8:_<+BN$,Ej5!(B $B$N2DG=@-$r9b$a$k!#$3$l$O%?%$0J30$NElFn%"%8%"=t9q$"$k$$$OB>$N?76=7P:Q=t9q$G$N(B $B;v>p$bF1$8;v$G$"$k!#8GDjAj>l@)$O$"$/$^$GH/E8ES>e9q$,0l;~E*$K:NMQ$9$kA
$B!!Bh;M$K!"4m5!H/@8$r7Y9p$9$k@h9T;XI8$H$=$l$i$r5R4QE*$K4F;k$9$k9q:]5!4X$b$7$/(B $B$O9q:]6(D4BN@)$,I,MW$G$"$k!#4m5!$NH/@8$,CY$l$?860x$N0l$D$K!";T>l$K$h$k%"%8%"(B $B7P:Q$X$N3Z4QO@$,$"$C$?!#$=$&$7$?3Z4QO@$KBP$7$FK\Mh7Y9p$rH/$9$Y$-(BIMF$B$O$=$NLr(B $B3d$r2L$?$9$3$H$,$G$-$J$+$C$?!#$=$&$7$?4pK\E*$J5!G=$N7gMn$P$+$j$G$J$/!"(BIMF$B$N(B $BLdBj$KBP$9$k%"%W%m!<%A$N;EJ}$KBP$7$F$b?tB?$/$N5?Ld!&HcH=$,$"$k(B{IMF $B$NBP1~$KBP$9$kHcH=$NBeI=E*$J$b$N$K$O!"(BSachs(1997), Krugman(1998c), Feldstein(1998a)$B$J$I$,$"$k!#(B}$B!#(BIMF$B$N2CLA9q7P:Q4F;k(B($B%5!<%Y%$%i%s%9(B)$B5!G=$N2~A1(B $B!&8~>e!"$b$7$/$O(BIMF$B$KBeBX$9$k?7$7$$?7AH?%$NAO@_(B{$B66K\M@65H!#(B}$B$J$I$O!"M-NO$J2~(B $BA10F$K@.$j$&$k$b$N$G$"$m$&!#$3$N0F$O(BIMF$B!"@$3&6d9T$*$h$S9q:]7h:Q6d9T(B(BIS)$B$N6b(B $BM;4FFDIt6I$r@Z$jN%$7$F!V9q:]6bM;4FFD5!9=!W$r@_N)$7!"(B(1)$B3F9q$N6bM;4FFDBN@)$N(B $B4F;k!"(B(2)$B3F9qEv6I$X$N5;=Q;XF3!">pJs8r49!"(B(3)$B9q:]E*5!4XEj;q2H$N4FFD!"(B(4)$B9q:](B $BE*;nJd$KF1$NE}7W@0Hw!"$N




$B;29MJ88%(B



$B;e@%LP(B(1998)$B!X$J$<6d9T$r5_$&$N$G$9$+!YElMN7P:Q?7Js
$B2,It8wL@(B(1996)$B!V6bM;4D6-$NJQ2=$H6bM;@/:v!W!XF|K\$N6bM;!YElMN7P:Q(B $B?7Js
$B>.@n1Q<#(B(1998a)$B!X9q:]DL2_%7%9%F%`$N0BDj@-!YElMN7P:Q?7Js
$B>.@n1Q<#(B(1998b)$B!V%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$NM}O@E*0LCV$E$1!W!X%"%8%"DL2_4m5!(B $B$N7P:Q3X!YElMN7P:Q?7Js
$B1|ED1Q?.(B(1998)$B!V6bM;%7%9%F%`$N@HO@
$B<(B(1996)$B!V%j%9%/$N4IM}$H8xE*@/:v!W!XF|K\$N6bM;!YElMN7P:Q?7(B $BJs
$B2O9g@590(B(1998)$B!VDL2_4m5!GH5Z$N%a%+%K%:%`$H6571!W!X7P:Q%;%_%J!O@
$B>.IMM55W(B(1998)$B!V(BIMF$B%Q%C%1!<%8$r$I$&I>2A$9$k$+!W!X7P:Q%;%_(B $B%J!O@
$B>.>>??(B(1998)$B!VDL2_4m5!$N1F6A$r=y!9$K
$BGr0fAaM3N$(B(1998a)$B!X;qK\0\F0$H7P:Q!"6bM;4m5!$K4X$9$k9M;!(B(1)$B!Y>EFn(B $BF#Bt3X2q(B

$BGr0fAaM3N$(B(1998b)$B!X;qK\0\F0$H7P:Q!"6bM;4m5!$K4X$9$k9M;!(B(2)$B!Y>EFn(B $BF#Bt3X2q(B

$B9bLZ?.Fs(B(1992)$B!XF~Lg9q:]6bM;!YF|K\I>O@
$BIpED??I'(B(1996)$B!V5^7c$J;qK\N.F~$HEl%"%8%"=t9q$N@/:vBP1~!W!X%"%8%"(B $B$N6bM;(B $B!&;qK\;T>l!YF|K\7P:Q?7J9
$BCfEg@:Li!J(B1998$B!K!V%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$O$J$<5/$C$?$N$+!W!X%"%8%"DL2_4m5!$N7P:Q3X!YElMN7P:Q?7Js
$BF|LnD>F;(B(1998)$B!VDL2_4m5!!&6bM;4m5!$KN)$A8~$+$&%?%$!W!X%"%8%"DL2_(B $B4m5!$N7P:Q3X!Y%o%$%90YBX8&5f2qJTCx!"ElMN7P:Q?7Js
$B;3K\1I<#(B(1998)$B!V7P:Q65<
$B%5%C%/%9!"%8%'%U%j!<(B(1998)$B!V;T>l$H9q2H(B(2)$B!'?76=9q!"
$B%U%'%k%I%9%?%$%sIW:J(B(1998)$B!V%"%8%"4m5!$N6571!'(BIMF$B!"2a>j2pF~Hr$1(B $B$h!WF|K\7P:Q?7J9!J(B1998$BG/#57n(B7$BF|!K(B

$B%V%i%$%s%@!
Agenor,P.R., J.S. Bhandari, and R.P.Flood (1992), ``Speculative Attacks and Models of Balance of Payments Crises,'' IMF Staff Papers, vol.39, No.2, pp.357-394.

Agenor, P.R. and R.P. Flood (1994), ``Macroeconomic Policy, Speculative Attacks, and Balance of Payments Crises,'' in F. van der Ploeg, ed., The Handbook of International Macroeconomics, Oxford:pp.224-250

Alba, Pedro, Amar Bhattacharya, Stijn Claessens, Swati Ghosh, and Leonardo Hernandez (1998).''Volatility and contagion in a financially-integrated world: lessons from East Asia's recent experience,''presented at the PAFTAD 24 conference.

Baro, R.J. and D.B.Gordon (1983) ``A Positive Theory of Monetary Policy in a Natural Rate Model,'' Journal of Political Economy, Vol.91, No.4, pp.589-610.

Calvo, G.A., Leiderman, and C.M. Reinhart (1993), $B!H(BCapital Inflows and Real Exchange Rate Appreciation in Latin America,$B!I(B IMF Staff Papers, Vol.40, No.1, pp.108-151.

Cline, William R. and Kevin J.S. Barnes (1997), $B!H(BSpreads and Risks in Emerging Markets Lending,$B!I(B Institute of International Finance Rsearch Paper, No.97-1,Novemver.

Corsetti, Giancarlo, Paolo Pesenti and Nouriel Roubini (1998). ``What caused the Asian currency and financial crisis?'' National Bireau of Economic Research Working Papers No.6833-6834, December.

Dornbusch, Rudiger (1998). ``Asian crisis themes,''mimeo, MIT, February.

Eichengreen, B., A.K. Rose, and C. Wyplosz (1996) $B!H(BContagious currency crises,$B!I(B NBER Working Paper, no.5681.

Doug Bandow (1999), $B!H(BIMF a problem, not a solution,$B!I(B The Japan Times (Sunday, January 24, 1999)

Eichengreen, B., A.K. Rose, and C. Wyplosz (1994) ``Speculative Attacks on Pegged Exchange Rates: An Empirical Explanation with Special Reference to the European Monetary System,$B!I(B NBER Working Paper, No.4898.

Eichengreen, B., A.K. Rose, and C. Wyplosz (1995), ``Exchange Market Mayhem: The Antecedents and Aftermath of Speculative Attacks,'' Economic Policy, Vol.21, pp.251-312.

Feldstein, Martin (1998a), $B!H(BReforcing the IMF,$B!I(B Foreign Affaires 1998, January/February.

Feldstein, Martin (1998b), ``Refocusing the IMF.'' Foreign Affairs 1998, March-April.

Garber, P.M. and L.E.O. Svensson (1995), ``The operation and Collapse of Fixed Exchange Rate Regimes,''in G. Grossman and K. Rogoff, ed., Handbook of International Economics, Vol.3, pp.1865-1911.

Giovannini, A. and F. Giavazzi (1989), Limiting Exchange Rate Flexibility, Cambridge, MIT Press.

Giavazzi, F. and M. Pagano (1988), $B!H(BThe Advantage of Tying One$B!G(B s Hands: EMS Discipline and Central Bank Credibility,$B!I(B European Economic Review, Vol.32, No.5, pp.1055-1082.

Goldfajn,I. and R.O.Valdes (1997), ``Capital Flows and the Twin Crises: The Role of Liquidity,'' IMF Working Paper, 97/98

Goldstein, Morris(1998), ``The Asian financial crisis: causes, cures, and systemic implications.'' Policy Analyses in International Economics No.55, Washington,DC: Institute for International Economics.

IMF (1995), International Capital Market: Developments, Prospects, and Kye Policy Issues, Washington, D.C.

IMF (1997), International Capital Market: Developments, Prospects, and Key Policy Issues, Washington, D.C.

IMF (1998). World economic outlook. Washington,DC: International Monetary Fund, December.

Krugman, Paul (1979). ``A model of balance of payments crises.'' Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 11: 311-325.

Krugman, P.R. (1994), $B!H(BThe Myth of Asia$B!G(Bs Miracle,$B!I(B Foreign Affairs 73(6), November/December, pp.62-78.

Krugman, P.R. (1996), ``Are Currency Crises Serl-fulfilling?'' NBER Macroeconomic Annual 1996, pp.345-378.

Krugman, P.R. (1998a), $B!H(BCurrency Crises,$B!I(B Unpublished manuscript. ( Krugman$B!G(Bs Webpage : http://web.mit.edu/lrugman/www/crises.html ).

Krugman P.R. (1998b), $B!H(BWhat happened to Asia?,$B!I(B Unpublished manuscript. (Krugman$B!G(Bs webpage : http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/DISINTER.html ).

Krugman P.R. (1998c), $B!H(BWill Asia bounce back?,$B!I(B Unpublished maniscript. ( Krugman$B!G(Bs webpage : http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/suisse.html).

Krugman P.R. (1998d), ``An open letter to Prime Minister Mahathir,'' Unpublished manuscript.(Krugman$B!G(Bs webpage : http:// web.mit.edu/ krugman/ www/ mahathir.html).

Kydland, F.E. and E.C. Prescott (1977) ``Rules rather than Discreation: The Inconsistency of Optimal Plans,'' Journal of Political Economy, Vo.85, No.3, pp.473-491.

McKinnon, R. (1991), The Order of Economic Liberalization, Johns Hopkins University Press.

McKinnon, R. and Pill, H. (1996), $B!H(BCredible liberalization and international capital flows: the overborrowing syndrome,$B!I(B in T. Ito and A.O. Krueger, eds., Financial Deregulation and Integration in East Asia, Chicago University Press.

Melitz, J. (1988), $B!H(BMonetary Discipline and Cooperation in the European Monetary System: A synthesis$B!I(B in Francesco Givazzi et al. eds., The European Monetary System, Cambridge University Press, pp.51-84.

Miller, V. (1996), ``Speculative Attacks with Endogenously Induced Commercial Bank Crises,'' Journal of International Money and Finance, Vol.15, No3, pp.383-403.

Obstfeld, M. (1986) ``Rational and Self-fulfilling Balance-of-Payments Crises,'' American Economic Review, Vol.76, No.1, pp.72-81

Obstfeld, M. (1994) ``The Logic of Currency Crises,'' Banque de France Cahiers Economiques et Monetaire, No.43, pp.189-213.

Obstfeld, M. (1995), $B!H(BInternational Currency Experience: New Lesoons and Lessons Relearned,$B!I(B Brooking Papers on Economic Activity, pp.119-195.

Obstfeld, M. (1996), ``Model of Currency Crises with Self-fulfilling Features,'' European Economic Review, Vol.40, No.3-5, pp.1037-1047.

Obstfeld, M. (1997), ``Destabilizing Effects of Exchange-rate Escape Clauses,'' Journal of International Economics, Vol.40, No.1/2, pp.61-77.

Sachs J. (1997), $B!H(BPower unto itself,$B!I(B Financial Times (1997. 12. 11)

Sachs J and Radelet S. (1998), ''The onset of the East Asian financial crisis,'' National Bureau of Economics Research Working Paper on Economic Activity No.1.

Rose, A.K. and L.E.O. Svensson (1994), ``European Exchange Rate Credibility before the Fall,'' European Economic Review, Vol.38, No.6, pp1185-1216.

Salant, S.W. and D.W. Henderson (1978), ``Market Anticipations of Government Policies and the Price Gold,'' Journal of Political Economy, vol.86, No.4, pp627-648.

Shiller, R. (1989), Market Volatility, Cambridge, MIT Press.

$B?^I=$N%Z!<%8(B






$B2,It8wL@$N%[!<%`%Z!<%8(B
SFC$B$N%[!<%`%Z!<%8(B
$BCx